Kinchley's Tavern

Very good thin crust, was a little floppy but the flavor was good

Delicious

Very solid pizza. Nice and crispy, great sauce. The pies and slices are super small, I could’ve killed two pies of this stuff. Not a superstar, but a very good pizza especially for up north.

Got a plain pie, and a vodka pie. Cheese pie was an 8.9, vodka pie was a 9.1. Overall, 9.0

Good crunch on crust, but toppings were overbearing and stole the show from a solid crust and tangy sauce. Some slices fell apart with weight of toppings.

Goooodddd stufffff

Great atmosphere. It was a good pizza.

Flavor was good, up until the crust. Bit crackery. Oily so didn’t hold up for being so thin. The vodka eggplant was gas

Perfect pie size. Crunch was good. Sauce was mediocre…dropped the score because of this. Cash only too…get with the times.

This pizza slaps

Not that great under carriage lots of flop good sauce good cheese crust was crispy I’m given this an 8 because I think I just went on a bad day I go here a lot and most of the time it’s crispy and has no flop

I think Kinchey’s has one fantastic bar pie. It’s really thin with great sauce and cheese, along with a stellar crust. It can be very greasy, but it’s overall a great pizza.

Got the fried eggplant pie great sauce great mozzarella top tier crust

Good sauce and crispy crust. No undercarriage

Very good and very thin bar pie. Cool atmosphere with lots of families eating. Bar is separated from dining area. Great crunch and taste to this perfectly cooked pie. Want to return and try some of the other menu items.

Great Pizza if you’re in the northern part of Jersey.

I would drive 1.5 hours for this pizza. The Fra Diavolo is worth writing home about.

Saggy but good crust. And above everything the price… a whole pie for under $15 in the urban northeast area… you won’t find cheaper pizza. Should raise the score to 8 just because of the price.

Seriously amazing thin crust bar pie!

If you like a Bar Pie or “Bar Stool Style” pizza, you will love this pie. This is a cracker thin, 14” pie with some decent char. There’s no reason to ask for well done or crispy, it will come that way automatically. Good cheese to sauce ratio. Sauce is good but not great, except the Vodka Pie which was delicious and IMO more of an Angry or Slightly Spicy Vodka. I have to admit that Thin Crust Bar Pie isn’t my favorite style but this is a great pie that is always consistent and will never disappoint. Definitely worth a drive for, it ranks up there with The Columbia Inn in Montville and a little behind Angeloni’s in Caldwell.