King Umberto's of Elmont

Re-heated metro pizza outstanding

King Umberto’s Rating - 7.5/10 Good pizza

Grandma 7.8 Regular 8.3

Regular slice 8.5 Grandma 7.9 Overall 8.2

Liked the regular more than the grandma. Great place to try. Sauce on the grandma was hitting.

Falling in line with Portnoy’s assessment. First piece of pizza since my string of North Dakotan pizza reviews. Classic NY slice, that had been reheated so it lost some decimal points overall. Still very solid. A bit greasy in the mouth, but not too bad to where it drips on your hand!

Crispy, little flop, great sauce, not too doughy or greasy. Love a little oregano baked into the slice. This slice is a winner

Crust, sauce, cheese all super flavorful. Not just hype, really solid pizza.

Traveled from Syosset to bring in takeout from King Umberto’s. Wow. Great N.Y. pizza. Had the metro and Neapolitan pie. Both Great

Regular slice has great crisp, great flavor, very oily which bring its down, and the crust/dough has ZERO flavor whatsoever..Regular is 7.8, good not great, however the grandma is fucking awesome, tons of flavor and crispy..8.3!

Regular: perfect crisp to the dough and you can tell it's a good quality cheese because of the lack of grease. The best part is the sauce, it has a good tang to it without putting sugar in it.8.8 Sicilan: not many places get this slice right. A serious crunch on this slice and again sauce and cheese are delicious,one of the best in NY in my opinion. 9.1 Grandma: this slice is really my style thin and crispy. This sauce is different than the other two slices and it is pure tomato flavor just amazing. 9 4

Above average football pizza. Classic ny slice with not too much flop and nice and thin. I would consider this great for Long Island but just very good in general.

Very good regular slice (8.2) & Grandma pizza (8.0), though the Grandma & Sicilian (7.4) is much better at Umberto’s. The Vodka pizza (7.8) & Metro pizza (7.4) were good, but not my favorites.

Standard bearer for football pizza in this neighborhood. Cooked well - dough, cheese and sauce all legit. Would eat here regularly.

Pretty damn good! Crispy crust and everything you’d want from a classic NY pizza

Metro pie was pretty solid, not too big a fan of the crust. Worth a try

Cooked perfectly, model football pizza. From top to bottom outstanding. More sauce could bump the score up but we’re circumcising mosquitoes at this point. It’s excellent.

Love the great tasting sauce on this slice. Real deal Italian old school flavor. Great crisp. Had a few slices while watching 2020 roll in. BTW the restaurant is no joke.

Always amazing, classic slice is up there with them all and the vodka slice is incredible as well

Really good. Great staff too.

Regular slice was dry, old, sitting, no cheese, like cardboard. After growing up on this my whole life, they have officially hit the skids!!! Mama Theresa and Unbertos new Hyde park for me only now