King’s New York Pizza | Martinsburg

Pretty good local slice. I would recommend getting it “Well done”. As you can see in the photo I ordered it that way (and always do here), and it still was a little on the not cooked enough side for me. Sauce is pretty good, but could use more of it.

Crust is good. But way to much cheese. Couldn’t even taste the sauce. Good slice if you like cheese.

Very floppy and greasy

Crust is great. Sauce is good. But the cheese is a 1/2” thick or more. Overkill. Heavy pie. If they dialed back the cheese amount it could get a higher score.

Greasy and chewy. Football pie.

Listen up, Here it is! In this area, there’s KINGS and then there’s everyone else. The ingredients they use are second to none and it comes through in every bite. I know a guy who’s family owns a pizza shop in the area, and he admits behind closed doors that his family’s place can’t compete. Each component of their pizza is just about perfect, anyone tells you otherwise, well... They have bad taste. This would be the only place locally that would be worthy of El Presidente’s review.