First off, oil was dripping like the freaking BP spill. Some flop, broke into pieces. An average slice of pizza for such a hyped pizza establishment.
raulfpizzacrew4/3/21, 10:04 p.m.
Just good pizza. Excellent cheese and sauce, just enough of both on a doughy but crispy crust. Nice overall taste. Would definitely get it again.
crispypie11/18/20, 6:09 p.m.
Note: This is a slice review. Not awful, not great but a slightly better than average Grandma slice. Crust around the edges and about two inches in we crisp but lost the crisp after that. The sauce taste was bold and took over the slice. As far as the Freehold, Howell part of Monmouth county it would rank in the top 20 for Grandma Slices but overall I’m not driving more than 20 minutes for the pizza.
rmcev8227/16/20, 6:06 p.m.
Decent flavor but one slice was over cooked and falling apart and the other slice was undercooked and chewy
neil.leone4/3/20, 10:51 p.m.
Big sticker on the window says ‘Brooklyn, NY.’ Well, this ain’t Brooklyn Frankie. Big NY flop, greasy, sauce and cheese tasty. Crust far too well done in comparison to the rest of the pie. That’s a review.
bigdickslices1/2/20, 12:26 a.m.
This slice started off more Soupy than Krispy, but got better towards the middle. This is where the taste of the cheese and the sauce really came through. The crust also brings this score up significantly. The quality of ingredients is there, but this slice left more to be desired in how it was cooked. Overall this place has plenty of specialty slices that look delightful.
tyler9x10/3/19, 5:13 p.m.
Very doughy slices, too thick for my liking and pretty greasy. The bottom is charred to give the illusion of crisp but one bite will and that slight yank you have to give to pull the bite away from the rest of the slice uncovers it's secret doughy texture to leave this in the low 6s. #getyacrispup
dillon.cronce8/9/19, 6:00 p.m.
Good Pizza overall, very crunchy crust. No flop. Sweet sauce. Decent cheese
collin06137/26/19, 12:34 a.m.
cheese had a great flavor and it was a good amount of grease, maybe a little too much. the sauce was just ok but there wasn’t even a lot of sauce in the first place, it was much more cheesy. it’s a good slice, but nothing to go out of your way for by all means.
jason.lam6/13/19, 4:19 p.m.
“I plain, not too crispy” A little floppy on his thinner crust, that nice and chewy. A lot of cheese & not too greasy but just not enough sauce.🍕
kingal5/20/19, 2:41 p.m.
Average pizza continues, just cause your Italian doesn’t mean you make great pizza. Crust was “Krispy” , bland cheese , Sauce was average.
joe.dejohn4/27/19, 1:22 a.m.
Definitely better than all the other places down here. Nice crunch. Krispy up.
vinnie.poogs2/16/19, 7:05 p.m.
Good slice, better than plain slice here which is average at best
eddymac12/30/18, 2:26 a.m.
crispy crust. above average sauce (not too much). cheese is great. love this pizza.
matt.madonna11/10/18, 10:08 p.m.
Grandma slice was a solid 6.4, but the buffalo slice I ate (not pictured) was an amazing 8.8. Crispy and hot, would recommend
daveturner11/3/18, 1:24 a.m.
Margherita & Grandma slice (pictured) Crust was crispy, sauce decent. I’ve had their regular slice, prefer the Grandma Slice.
carlos.velazquez9/29/18, 8:24 p.m.
A forgetful slice. Notice the fake cheese right away, no “mmmm” with the bite. Dry crust, wouldn’t dive for it at a party.