L & B Spumoni Gardens

Pizza was bit over rated will not travel from the Bronx for this.. the guy who recommended it sucks Balls!

Great square joint. I love the sauce 🍕 🍕 🍕

Nothing special , square Slice is chewy & regular slice is ok nothing great about it

Round slice was o.k, I've had much better. Sicilian Square was better in my opinion but again an aquired taste.. Not much flavor for a Sicilian. Was disappointed.

Classic

Legendary Brooklyn spot, their loyal customers swear by their square slices here. The regular circular pies are ok, nuttin to brag about, but the squares are definitely a level up. A little too saucy & heavy for my liking, but very tasty. Not the best square slices around but you could do a lot worse.

Banging

One of the best Sicilian slices I’ve ever had (didn’t have a pic)

Never disappoints… melts in your mouth

While not as good as years past, it is still excellent at L&B’s. The squares are definitely a little smaller, but still has the quality taste. Will always come back.

Perfect crust, the bite is the best part. Super tangy sauce, wish there was more cheese

Would’ve loved a real well done pie rather than a ready to go but this pie was everything it’s supposed to be, still crunchy charred edge while remaining soft but not to doughy. Cheese has great pull and it’s melted so nicely to the dough you can’t tell we’re it started but the sauce is the star. The pie might’ve aged through the years but it’s a timeless sauce sweet l with a bit of zest topped off by that grated cheese. This pie is amazing and there are clones that beat this but the original always satisfies!! Love coming back

One of the thicker slices I’ve eaten, but still highly effective and interesting. Obviously if you’re coming here, you’re getting the square, which is what I got. Ingredients were of serious quality, cheese to sauce ratio was immense, and the doughiness of this slice is no joke. Not my favorite style of pizza but a worthwhile trip for sure. 8.5

Worth it Best Sicilian in New York

Quality Brooklyn pizza. Square slice with the cheese below the sauce is fantastic.

Nostalgia aside, the best square pizza in NYC! It’s the one that others imitate, or die trying. I say nostalgia because I’ve been eating here since I was a kid, and I’m pushing double nickels, so that’s a long time. Worth the trip here to try, grab a half a tray and eat a few pieces on the drive home. Enjoy…

Best Brooklyn slice ever

My families favorite pizza place