Best Sicilian I’ve ever bit into.
kevin.price1/20/22, 2:33 a.m.
Would’ve loved a real well done pie rather than a ready to go but this pie was everything it’s supposed to be, still crunchy charred edge while remaining soft but not to doughy. Cheese has great pull and it’s melted so nicely to the dough you can’t tell we’re it started but the sauce is the star. The pie might’ve aged through the years but it’s a timeless sauce sweet l with a bit of zest topped off by that grated cheese. This pie is amazing and there are clones that beat this but the original always satisfies!! Love coming back
alex.silberstein12/28/21, 6:46 p.m.
One of the thicker slices I’ve eaten, but still highly effective and interesting. Obviously if you’re coming here, you’re getting the square, which is what I got. Ingredients were of serious quality, cheese to sauce ratio was immense, and the doughiness of this slice is no joke. Not my favorite style of pizza but a worthwhile trip for sure. 8.5
stainy12/18/21, 7:17 p.m.
Quality Brooklyn pizza. Square slice with the cheese below the sauce is fantastic.
n.rudy12/5/21, 6:37 a.m.
Nostalgia aside, the best square pizza in NYC! It’s the one that others imitate, or die trying. I say nostalgia because I’ve been eating here since I was a kid, and I’m pushing double nickels, so that’s a long time. Worth the trip here to try, grab a half a tray and eat a few pieces on the drive home. Enjoy…
antony.vengerovskiy10/1/21, 1:59 a.m.
Square slice is something special. Truly worth the hype. The regular slice however isn’t the greatest and compared to the squads which is a solid 8.5, the Reggie brings down that overall score.
arthur.collins9/27/21, 10:52 p.m.
Great square sauce on top great crust , Don’t think El President got good slice
bfd10758/13/21, 9:17 p.m.
The upside down square, sweet and tangy sauce. Light crispy crust a classic pie.