antony.vengerovskiy10/1/21, 1:59 a.m.
Square slice is something special. Truly worth the hype. The regular slice however isn’t the greatest and compared to the squads which is a solid 8.5, the Reggie brings down that overall score.
arthur.collins9/27/21, 10:52 p.m.
Great square sauce on top great crust , Don’t think El President got good slice
bfd10758/13/21, 9:17 p.m.
The upside down square, sweet and tangy sauce. Light crispy crust a classic pie.
neil.mcguinness6/24/21, 6:09 p.m.
The source was very delicious. The cheese was very flavorful. The crust was very good. I love this pizza.
chase.levy6/23/21, 4:24 a.m.
The fluffy chewy dough melts in your mouth. The sauce is supreme. The subtle layer of mozzarella is a treat. The charred edges are light and airy. It’s a marvel a pizza like this exists. Maybe not for everyone but most definitely for me. Bensonhurst BK all the way baby! Finish off with some spumoni or ices and it’s well worth the ride from anywhere in the tri-State.
jtm27276/12/21, 9:32 p.m.
An update to my previous review, where I underrated it with a 7.4. I’ve gone here a few times since and have liked it more with every visit (part of it was that the pizza wasn’t 100% hot when I went last time). This square is the real deal, even if I’ve found it to be an acquired taste. True Brooklyn atmosphere, top-notch sauce, chewy dough, crispy crust, not too doughy for a Sicilian. Feel obligated to give an improved score that more accurately reflects my thoughts on this place. Definitely the real deal, compared to the more artisanal/dressed up squares you’d find on Prince Street. Highly recommend for a real Brooklyn experience.
davin.moskal6/1/21, 3:36 a.m.
Not sure if the Sicilian is technically the plain slice but the “round” slice is not good. I’ll ignore it so the Sicilian is pretty decent, fluffy, crispy crust with the sauce on top