L & B Spumoni Gardens

A lot of these places try but they don’t succeed. This is how it’s done. The Brooklyn Classic. The middle is the best slice. Get yourself a middle and you’ll be good. A lot of ppl are always like “they changed!” They changed what? Their prices but they still have the taste that ppl trust. That being said don’t ever get the friggin round, it’s terrible. The Sicilano is an 8.8.

Sorry Dave, we usually agree on our scores, maybe it is a Boston thing! But this is no 7.9 this is a must go to and must get the square slices this is an 8.5!

Good solid slice. Tasty good cheese and sauce

great sauce , consistently great pizza for over 50 years

The Sicilian slice is a slice I could have every single day. It’s such a solid piece of pizza. The sauce is fresh. The cheese is the perfect amount. And the CRUST and BREAD…so good. The bread is so fluffy, which I feel many Sicilian slices get wrong. The bread separates this one from others. A bit more crisp would take it over the top, but it’s my favorite Sicilian slice in any case.

Great balance of sauce and cheese. Perfectly cooked, great thickness. Very interested to see how it will reheat.

This Brooklyn institution has one of the best sweet sauces I’ve ever had. Crust was perfectly cooked and everything blended together well. Sicilian pie is a must get if you’re in the area.

Really good pizza it’s a little burnt but totally worth it this was worth traffic. We were literally trying to go to a Christmas thing we literally were trying to find a spot for like 20 minutes we didn’t get out of the car. It was that crowded this was worth the wait

Iconic square slice from Brooklyn in the 90s you couldn’t beat it an over 30 years later it is still a superior slice

Solid!

Good crisp under carriage. New vodka slices are the bomb!! I am fat so this was like my 17th slice

Vodka slice - new

simply incredible. would die in this sauce. great crispy n pretty light could down 7 of these easy fr

Great upside down pie but I will admit the hype is a bit much.

Not sure what the hype is about this place. The famous square wasn’t particularly good and the triangle was subpar at best. Get real