Upside down Sicilian pie. Crispy crust. Great sauce. Surprised me how good it was
lennoll13/17/23, 6:19 p.m.
Couldn’t resist the nice selection of specialty slices. Great tasting lunch
jared-pizza4/23/22, 4:07 a.m.
Sauce and cheese were amazing. Pretty nice crust, I appreciate the doughiness but just slightly too chewy for my taste. Definitely will come back here
jrzanyc6/2/21, 10:59 p.m.
Ok another no mask review. this time ay La Modona in Matawan. Pretty good spot. Slice had a nice crisp on the dough with no flop. cheese was good quality and sauce had decent flavor... decent football pie slice... 7.5 thats the review
nicole.rosado3/16/21, 6:02 p.m.
Best Pizza outside of Brooklyn!! Especially the upside pie!! SCRUMPTIOUS
shane.whelan1/24/21, 6:11 p.m.
First One Bite review. Never had La Madona pizza before, just their entrees which I know are good. Wasn’t bad, had a nice touch of garlic to it. Cheese was a bit of a separatist. I would go there again. BBQ chicken pizza was probably a 7.2 - chicken was a little dry, less BBQ for my liking. None of it was freshly made, all from display and reheated, but to be fair that’s how most of my reviews will be.
14 views•0 likes
tom.petry1/4/21, 6:32 p.m.
I had a plan slice before the Sicilian... plain slice was ok way to much cheese... sauce is little to sweet for my liking and you can really taste the spices on this Sicilian....
lauri.cammarata5/3/20, 8:01 p.m.
Brought back memories from Brooklyn’s Spumoni Gardens. Really good pizza.
barberovdayear4/20/20, 10:26 p.m.
The square upside down gets an 8.3 for me. Once quarantine is over I’ll go in and try a plain slice and see where that’s at
anthony.cammarata4/5/20, 10:30 p.m.
Good sauce and cheese combo, crust cooked nicely on the crispy side. A little too floppy for my taste. Reminds me of the Pizza places on the Avenue growing up.
pizzadoc.jv1/23/20, 5:12 p.m.
Eh...maybe I'm a little low, but not by much. Maybe a 6.4 instead but a review is a review. I'm sticking with the 6.2 that I originally gave. Decent slice. My average slice is a 6.1 and this is about that. I also got a grandma slice that I did not review on camera. I love grandma slices and normally score them high. Grandma here is a 5.5 which was disappointing. Will try this place again as I think this may have been a bad day. Heard a lot of great things about this spot so worth giving them another chance. Sauce was good on regular slice. You can tell they know their pizza. Just expected a bit more.
12 views•2 likes
joe.carfagno12/29/19, 12:31 a.m.
Above average upside down Sicilian slice. Would come back for their regular pizza.
jason.lam8/25/19, 4:41 p.m.
“1 plain, not too crispy.” A bit floppy but doesn’t matter, their sauce is great. An ideal sauce to cheese ratio & very nice dough. Their upside down is the best around though!! Standard slice 7.1 Upside down 7.7
chadt8/13/19, 8:46 p.m.
Cheese was a little sloppy, little bit too much grease. good sauce and cheese flavor, good crust
just_the_tippp6/26/19, 12:05 a.m.
Really solid pie! Could use a little more sauce but cheese is excellent!
kingal4/22/19, 9:05 p.m.
This pizza slice was served smoking hot, hence the excess oil. It was a good slice, nice sauce and good dough.
jumbo12/9/18, 3:05 a.m.
Juicey. Great slice. Good strong sauce with a parmesan and mozz combo. Crispy crust with a solid finish