La Piazza Pizza and Tap

very solid slice, no flop, sauce is delish but the cheese blend is different not my favorite. Grandma pie was amazing very fluffy and doughy all 3 sauces were very good. Would go back for the grandma

Plain slice solid, didn’t love the cheese blend. Grandma slice was excellent

Alright La Piazza. This type of pizza right here is when someone says “pizza is pizza” and let me tell ya that’s not good for La Piazza. This is second rate garbage. I got the friggin thing well done and it was like biting into a 3 dollar whores pussy. You know what this pizza is? It’s Mets Pizza. Should had known with Piazza in the title. This is Mets Pizza. Yeah it will get ya over for a evening. But if you have taste. Then you go someplace else. Sorry La Piazza. Maybe change your name to LA Knight and you’ll have better pizza.

Good pizza, different tasting sauce.

Pizza is always well made and tastes great.

Pretty good classic NYC slice. Good crisp, makes me feel like a kid eating at your local pizzeria.

Fantastic. Nice crisp. Lots of flavor.

Fresh out the oven. Sauce was not doing it, crust was pretty decent.

Fast friendly service. Been so long since I had pizza in NY. Everything I remembered it to be.

Slightly above average

...I use to eat at this place a lot and considered it as one of the top pizza gem in the Island..but quality has fallen off. Good enough on a drunk day pizza not a top choice sober however.

Really good thin slice and cheesy

Chicken fra diavolo and vodka sauce slices! I stop every time I'm in Staten Island! It's on point!

Very oily crust was blah. Not great but I’ve had worse

Specialty Slices - eaten there. Had Chicken Marsala and eggplant today. I wasn’t going to rate individual specialty slices, but here I go anyway. They have a great selection of rolls and specialty slices here. They all are very good. Fresh quality ingredients, and evidently made with care and pride. I get the regular Sicilian here sometimes too. It’s a little like the Brothers Pizza acclaimed square, but not quite. Not that it has any bearing in my score, but the staff here goes out of their way to be very friendly. A little different that the other place I just mentioned here.