La Scala Ristorante Pizzeria

Best local option. Nothing beats their mikes hot honey Sicilian. Feels like home

Sauce is great definitely one of the best in the area, cheese ratio is good, crust is a pinch on on the thicker side but overall a great tasting pizza.

Long overdue review, its like they dont care, undercarriage was like a babys butt, no crisp, no color, it literally looked like renz badabing after a winter in stoney , next

Very solid pizza, great quality ingredients! I suggest you get it right out of the oven instead of heated up. Highly recommend the Sicilian, classic and then mommas!

One of the best spots in Commack

Classic football pizza can set my hair too

The chicken franchese slice here is one for the books. Tender chicken with a creamy lemon sauce and quality mozzarella. A little flop from the weight of the toppings.

This was sooooooooo close to being in the 8’s.. this is a great “football slice” right here. Very little flop, good crisp. Mayyybeeee a TOUCH too much oil and a TOUCH less cheese. But I’m not complaining at all, I can eat this forever… I’d be very happy if this is where I grabbed my football pie from. The Grandma looked great but I didn’t get it… I’m on a diet ay oh.

Great crunch. Zero flop. Great taste. Tad greasy. Good football pizza.

Sloppy, Salty, no sauce

Needs a little more flavor on top. Good consistency!

Good Slice

La Scala Rating - 7.9/10 Great pizza. Excellent garlic knots.

I love what the prez calls football pizza and this is one of the best on the island. I have been coming here for decades and it has always been one of my favs for regular cheese pizza. The garlic knots from the back are fantastic as well. Everything else is hit or miss

Very basic pie with too much soupy cheese and a doughy crust

Regular: very crispy slice. Heavy on the cheese. Sauce is sweet. 7.3 Sicilan margarita: dough is light and crispy. No cheese on this slice. Again sauce is sweet 7.8

Small NY flop, very good sauce, and average crust. FANTASTIC buffalo slice, definitely recommend getting a specialty slice here

Slight NY flop, good sauce, crust had a good initial crunch to it. Overall slightly above average slice. Buffalo is 7.7

Right up my alley. Fantastic LI slice. Good structure, Great sauce and flavor balance. Crust is good too. Will definitely be returning