The grandma slice was amazing. Much better than the regular cheese slice. Both were crispy, the grandma slice was very thin. The cheese slice needed more sauce and less cheese. The crust however was very delicious and one of the better crusts made.
matthew.divozzo3/20/21, 11:31 p.m.
Love the crust. Great crisp on it. Very fresh dough. Did a great job with the seasoning. Nice traditional pie. Would eat it for breakfast, lunch and dinner.
lennoll13/2/21, 6:11 p.m.
Two fine slices here, but I’ll rate their signature square, a saucy crunchy delight known as “The Palermo”. A tasty version of the traditional Grandma pie, had probably been sitting in the case a while. Worth a visit, but order a whole fresh Palermo! Marg slice was solid too. Terrific crust.
ddpack122/27/21, 4:02 a.m.
The Palmero Pizza is great. Thin, crispy, well done crust. No flop. Sauce is full of flavor.
spiceymeatballs2/20/21, 8:54 p.m.
It’s a basic solid slice, needed more sauce, good crisp, however a little too thick , no flop.
pizzagavone6/14/20, 10:59 p.m.
This is ok, not good and very far off of an 8. It’s a decent pizza. Also got the pomodoro, good not wonderful.
eliyahu.kheel4/12/20, 6:24 p.m.
Really top notch pizza! The sauce was phenomenal! I will say however that it was one of the worst tasting pizzas cold that I've had.
forgetaboutit10/21/19, 8:41 p.m.
INCREDIBLE SAUCE! may be my absolute favorite pizza sauce, correction it is my favorite, the flavor is unbelievable. Crust is nice and thin and crunchy! Thin layer of cheese on the bottom, a little more cheese or another thin layer on top and this is 9.2 or higher... similar to one of my favorites Brunos Pizza in clifton except there are no middles and there cheese is mixed in with the sauce so you get a little more cheese which is why its in the 9s, id LaSicilia cut out the middle slices and added a bit of more cheese its hands down in the 9s .. over all GREAT FREAKING PIE FRANKIE!!!! I will be back
sgtpet10/15/19, 4:57 p.m.
Little flop. Good crunch. Excellent flavor cheese. Unique flavored cheese.
michael.stefanelli8/18/19, 9:35 p.m.
Decent crisp, maybe a little light on sauce and char but it is solid.
ryan.rutherford7/14/19, 12:08 a.m.
The regular cheese pizza is good, like a 7.2 but the marquee item here is the Palermo pie. Essentially a “Grandma pie,” it’s incredibly flavorful and delicious. Thin & crispy, sauce bursting with flavor from the sweet crushed tomatoes mixed with garlic & oregano. It’s very similar to a hot version of bruschetta. There is a super thin layer of cheese underneath the sauce. If they melted a little fresh mozzarella on top, this pie would be in the 9s. But overall a very, very good pizza.
ed.mckeown4/27/19, 3:49 p.m.
Main score is based in the regular slice. Fantastic pizza, never stopped here before always heard good things and boy am I not disappointed. The margarita slice tastes as you expect, nothing special but yes still good.
rob.fagan4/22/19, 10:48 p.m.
Frankie, it’s a messy slice Frankie. Sauce has a fantastic taste. Sauce on top of cheese like Spumoni Gardens in Brooklyn. But crust is thinner and crispier. Rookie whole number score, but would like to give it a 7.95 so on the scale I put it at 8.0. Side note, one bite everyone knows the rules, this score is based on a corner slice. If I scored the middle slice first, it would drop down 2 points. Ask for an end or corner.
ron.wis1/3/19, 8:33 p.m.
Got a half bacon half plain. They didn't cut the bacon up but that's one of the few mistakes. A lot of flop but crust has a nice crunch still and the flavor on the sauce is pleasant. A really good pie.
apiewelldone12/27/18, 4:19 a.m.
La Sicilias Palermo pie. Very good authentic pie. Very thin and crispy, with a thin layer of mozzarella underneath chunky sauce and grated cheese. If you like grandma pies, you will like this one. Only complaint was it was a little too well done.
john.dekenipp12/6/18, 12:23 a.m.
As you'll see in the review I did not review the plain pizza. I went with their highly renowned Palermo Pie. It did not disappoint and it absolutely lived up to the hype. Highly recommend it.
318 views•9 likes