Lazzara's Pizza Cafe

Tasty but definitely not in the 9s. Sauce is watery and non existent below the cheese. Thin crust, but very one-dimensional and cracker-like. Sauce has a note of Celeste pizza (but a MUCH better version). Again it’s tasty and not a bad value, but not elite.

Fire. Thin slice. No flop. Great sauce. Great cheese. Doesn’t seem like a grab a slice and go place. But super cool old school NY dine in spot. Absolutely would go back and recommend.

1/2 cheese and 1/2 Hot Honey with Pep. This was amazing.

Very crispy, toppings stayed intact, and the char on the crust was perfect.

Crispy thin with amazing sauce and incredible cheese flavor and texture.

Crust is next level, cracker like. Sauce is sweet and has a nice tang to it. Cheese is solid.

This place as a whole was a lot higher of a score

Great sauce, nice char bite around the edge. Thin but filling and a great what I’d call Grandma pie. I got mine with chunky pepperoni. I think maybe I should have tried first time just plain to get a baseline. Will be back!

I don’t understand how Portnoy gave this a 9.3. I think he was bribed or threatened by the mafia

Wow. So different, so good.

It honestly tasted like a decent frozen pizza. The service was also awful.

One bite, everyone knows the rules… and one bite is all I wanted. Did Dave get paid to do this review and score them this high? Because no way was this a 9.3. The crust was good, sauce was basically tomato soup. The saltiness of this pie definitely didn’t want me leaving more. Shoulda just went back to Joe’s. Trusted Dave and was disappointed.

Great pizza. Only reason it’s not a higher score is I found the sauce a bit too sweet for my personal taste

Incredible pizza… solid 8.9. & the basic House Margarita was delicious too with a 9.1!!

Great crunch, sauce wasn’t my favorite, not the biggest fan of the tomato soup flavor. only downside to it imo. Still great pizza

Not a traditional “NY slice”

Very very good. Better than any pizza I have around me home in Orlando. Idk if I have ever had a 9/10 or 10/10 pizza but this was definitely up there. Sauce had a nice sweetness to it, cheese was fine, crust was amazing. Great crisp. Great crunch. Also the vibes inside the place are immaculate. Gives off old school hole in the wall pizza place. We like.