Lazzara's Pizza Cafe

Very good. But was expecting much better

Pizza sauce and cheese were good. First time I disagree with Dave. It was like eating pizza on a tortilla!!

Sauce was incredible my favorite part about the pie incredibly crispy and light! Highly recommend if staying in time square ambience is also nice! Staff was great and super helpful too!

Love that it’s super thin. Great pizza. I loved the Margarita pizza more than the cheese.

Alrighty Frankie…got a half a sausage pizza. Light and crispy. Great flavor. This is a pizza you travel across the city for. Small frontage- like a nice little joint in the 1950s. Definitely visiting again. Must visit!

The sauce was too sweet.

One of the best pizzas I’ve ever tried!!! Seems a little sketchy at first but seriously give this place a try! Best vibes and AMAZING pizza

Yeah, this is pretty unique. I thought the crust would’ve had burnt edges with caramelized cheese, but it’s just crispy edges. It’s a very thin crust cracker style pizza with a very sweet sauce and a mild cheese, but it is darn good. I was surprised by the buffalo, it was a mix of what seems like buffalo honey and red sauce, but it actually was very good. This place is worth hitting for sure.

Sauce is very sweet. Crust rocks, super thin. Cheese is nice and a tad salty. Pepperoni is deli style and hot honey hits. Solid pie

An absolute stunner!!! The crispness and taste was something I’ve never had before. The ambiance felt as if we was having friends over to watch football and eat pizza. A must visit.

Ordered the clam and garlic and the special which looks like it had prosciutto, sun dried tomatoes and olives. The clam pie was better but neither were mind blowing.

StoolPresidente nailed it with this one. SuperLight, crispy, great thin crust, great sauce. I could eat 4 whole pies.

Sadly confused over the hype. A cracker with sweet sauce and cheese here and there.

Wow wow wow!!! Thin crust and crispy edges. So so so good.

Very sweet and greasy in a great way, perfectly charred. Not a big thin crust guy but it delivered!

Probably the best pizza I’ve ever had honestly. Unique with the thin crust square pizza but incredibly flavorful sauce and good crispiness

I do not understand the rest of these reviews. This pizza is just a flatbread and it’s just okay… Angelo’s Coal Oven, up the street, that is also in the 9’s from Portnoy is way better than this. Based on how old this video is, it might be time for him to do some second reviews because obviously his grading scale has changed over the years.

Nirvana

High quality, pep to be desired but cheese would go crazy

Definitely not a 9.3!! The pizza is good don’t get me wrong. I was torn between a 8.1 and 7.9. It was a bit soft in the middle and the sauce had a twang that wasn’t my favorite. The cheese was really good! The edges have a great crunch and the dough tasted good.

Pepperoni. Thin and light. Could easily crush a full size alone.