Lazzara's Pizza Cafe

Wow. So different, so good.

It honestly tasted like a decent frozen pizza. The service was also awful.

One bite, everyone knows the rules… and one bite is all I wanted. Did Dave get paid to do this review and score them this high? Because no way was this a 9.3. The crust was good, sauce was basically tomato soup. The saltiness of this pie definitely didn’t want me leaving more. Shoulda just went back to Joe’s. Trusted Dave and was disappointed.

Great pizza. Only reason it’s not a higher score is I found the sauce a bit too sweet for my personal taste

Incredible pizza… solid 8.9. & the basic House Margarita was delicious too with a 9.1!!

Great crunch, sauce wasn’t my favorite, not the biggest fan of the tomato soup flavor. only downside to it imo. Still great pizza

Not a traditional “NY slice”

Very very good. Better than any pizza I have around me home in Orlando. Idk if I have ever had a 9/10 or 10/10 pizza but this was definitely up there. Sauce had a nice sweetness to it, cheese was fine, crust was amazing. Great crisp. Great crunch. Also the vibes inside the place are immaculate. Gives off old school hole in the wall pizza place. We like.

It’s bad. Please save yourself the time and IGNORE Portnoy’s review; he was either paid or high or both. Not trying to be contrarian. He got John’s of Bleeker 100% right. But this pizza here is just not remotely good. Sauce is super weird, cheese has no flavor and crust is too. It’s crispy which is why I guess he liked it but that’s about all I can say that’s positive. Maybe their Italian food is good but the pizza is really bad.

High quality and good, you definitely need a few slices to get the feel of it.

If you like thin crust crunch pizza this is the spot but I enjoy thicker doughy crust

Gas

As good as food can get. A perfect pizza. The gluten free pizza is 10/10. MUST HAVE WHEN VISITING NEW YORK

What a class little Italian place that serves half and whole super thin pies. This really hit the spot with a great amount of sauce which was a little sweet. It’s up a small residential stairway entrance, if you blink you’ll miss it.

Very good. But was expecting much better

Pizza sauce and cheese were good. First time I disagree with Dave. It was like eating pizza on a tortilla!!

Sauce was incredible my favorite part about the pie incredibly crispy and light! Highly recommend if staying in time square ambience is also nice! Staff was great and super helpful too!

Love that it’s super thin. Great pizza. I loved the Margarita pizza more than the cheese.

Alrighty Frankie…got a half a sausage pizza. Light and crispy. Great flavor. This is a pizza you travel across the city for. Small frontage- like a nice little joint in the 1950s. Definitely visiting again. Must visit!