Not overly impressed on the first bite but by the end, a really good pizza. Excellent crunch!
brian.cohen512/15/19, 1:31 a.m.
Not only was the pie amazing but the shrimp parm and eggplant parm were some of the best I have had!
dryfs12/14/19, 11:42 p.m.
Best Pizza I have ever had!!! Amazing atmosphere!! Owner is a beauty!
alicia.nyc12/11/19, 10:32 p.m.
Dave, are you kidding me? 9.3???? Absolutely over-rated! The pizza was extremely salty, nothing special about the crust. It’s just unfair that Di Fara is only 9.4 where the pizza provides the most gourmet experience and here I don’t find any tasteful insight.
michael.waller112/10/19, 4:52 p.m.
Love this pizza! I prefer more sauce than cheese and also thin crust. This place really hit the mark. The pepperoni slices are also very good. Highly recommend.
megclassy12/10/19, 7:01 a.m.
I live here, and have grown up trying pizza around NYC my entire life. Went here to see what the hype was about, and sadly this fell VERY short. First off, it’s a minimum of 3 square slices, and the waiter kept pressuring us to get the full pie, but no one pressures me. The pizza was so bland that I wasn’t sure if I was eating cardboard with extra cheese or not. I prefer thin crust pizza, but this was so disappointing. Please don’t pay this place, it’s also kind of dirty, go to Rose’s two blocks over in Penn Station for an easy 8.6.
marquist12/10/19, 4:30 a.m.
REALLY not sure what all the hype is about. Crust was crumbly and reminded me of gluten free bread. Way too much sauce, not enough cheese. Sauce tasted sort of bland and over salted. Also this place hasn’t passed its sanitary inspection... tried roses at penn station earlier this day and it blew this place out of the water.
stephanie.eger12/9/19, 3:17 a.m.
I know it’s frowned upon to give any place a 10, so I won’t do that... however, I gave Lazzara’s pretty close to that. This was hands down the best pizza I have ever had in my life (so far). It’s thin, it’s FULL of flavor, it has a nice crunch to it. You can mix up your toppings and get half the pizza (3 slices) one way and half as something else- which makes it super convenient to try all the different pizzas they have. I literally have zero complaints. Everything was amazing. Also, I started with a salad and it was the best dressing ever. Sadly for me I don’t live in NYC so I can’t go get it anytime I want —BUT you can order this pizza and dressing and get it sent to you (nationwide). I’ll keep you posted on how that turns out :)
mitch.kaufman112/8/19, 3:33 p.m.
Very disappointing! What was Dave thinking? I make better pizza at home on a pizza stone. Too much flop for a small slice, and the sauce tasted like ketchup. It’s not just about thin crust