anthony.pulice1/17/20, 5:21 p.m.
Crispy thin crust. Great cheese sauce balance. Quality slice. Best I’ve had in nyc since johns on bleecker.
ramsey.morris1/16/20, 4:54 p.m.
Really fucking good pizza sausage was delicious, great crust, tangy sauce.
matt.proctor11/16/20, 2:29 p.m.
Pretty good. Sauce was too sweet. Decent overall, but definitely not in the 8-9 range.
scott.fennell1/15/20, 1:15 a.m.
The sauce was good however the thinness of the pizza makes it taste like a cracker. Was nowhere near 9.3
spacecase1/14/20, 11:28 p.m.
Way, way overrated. Dave should redo this one. Tasted more like a single layer of lasagna on an uncooked noodle. Tomato sauce was okay but the rest was a mess.
czechowhat1/13/20, 2:34 a.m.
Good. Not great. Sauce is awesome. Cheese is cheese. Crust is good. Somehow it is thin and dense at the same time. Don’t get me wrong, it’s a solid pie. Just not a 9.3.
mike.m551/12/20, 9:54 p.m.
Small 2nd floor place, pizza came out piping hot which was a plus. Thin crust style pan pizza, nice burnt edges.
andrew.smedberg1/12/20, 7:35 p.m.
Totally lived up to the hype Dave and their “best NY thin crust pizza” motto. It’s crispy, it’s fresh, it might be the best pizza I’ve had in NY. This is a must go if you’re within 60 miles of the place.
ryan.nevers1/12/20, 6:55 p.m.
If this is “New Yorks Best Pizza” than Ive had better in North Carolina... Went here because of the Presidents rating. Decent crust, thats about it. Seemed like a nicely cooked frozen thin crust pizza. Nice atmosphere, nice employees, just dont see how this gets a better review than Sally’s in New Haven.
pizzamayor1/12/20, 11:44 a.m.
Definitely not a 9.3! Was like eating Boboli With Ragu! Very disappointed at Dave’s review!
shawn.hibbs1/12/20, 12:20 a.m.
Pizza is thin crust but had good flop. Crust was maybe one of best I’ve had even though edges are slightly burnt. Sauce and cheese have good flavor with a little sweetness. Cheese was chewy. Overall, pizza was good but may have suffered slightly from high expectations. Still worth a try though.
michael.bulmer1/11/20, 1:18 a.m.
Welcome to the show. Thin crust. Top notch cheese. Tangy sauce.
chris-l1/10/20, 3:35 p.m.
The sauce is spectacular. Crust is good. So far my fav spot in New York.
amy.taweel1/10/20, 1:40 a.m.
The sauce tastes just like Gram use to make. I loved how simple this pizza is and yet so much flavor. Made my last trip to NYC!
michael.ferguson51/10/20, 1:19 a.m.
I love the cometary from the Prez...I happened to be in NYC and was only a mile from this location and jumped at a chance to try a 9.3. I was so unimpressed by this pie. Sauce was good crust flavor and cheese were a let down! It was 4 of us and we all felt the same way. I lived in Italy for years and have been a chef for over 23 years at ultra fine dining restaurants and never have I been let down by a restaurant review that I whole heartily believed like I was by this place. Side note arugula goat cheese salad very good! Sorry Prez I hope the next place I try on your covenant 9+ list redeems you.
breezy.wynn1/9/20, 12:16 a.m.
Holy shit, this is it! Get it, get it now. This pie is a freight train of delicious perfection!
rich.hogan11/7/20, 7:38 p.m.
Great ultra thin crust pizza with a sweet sauce. Great atmosphere!! Bohemian. Upstairs and through a curtain. A piece of old New York. It’s a bar restaurant. A hidden gem.