Lenny and Johns Pizzeria

Good flop, nice pie

Quality New York slice. Good crust. Grandma was also good.

I’ve had decent pizza here but this was comical 16” pie that would remind you of something you would have at chuck e cheese

Decent Slice. Nothing Special. Your average Football Pizza.

Not a bad slice, kinda greasy but crispy and pretty good taste.

Good slice Frankie

Very good slice - I can see why a lot of people rave about this place. Very little flop, good cheese + sauce and great crust. I also got the chicken slice too in which I give an 8.2 only because I love specialty slices especially ones with chicken.

Blah.

Super floppy. A bit greasy... deff a football pizza. Alright but not great

Best Cheese yet. Super floppy soggy crust. Overall a very flavor-packed slice

Pretty bland slice. Not too much flavor in the sauce. I had to add oregano and garlic powder for it to taste halfway decent. Crust was tasty. Cheese was just standard.

Huge Brooklyn fwop: messy, greasy pepperoni pie. Flavors were all there, good sauce, good cheese, right amount of salt. Dough was on the lighter side, but crust was chewy enough. It did need a few more minutes in the oven. Overall, good neighborhood spot.

Vodka slice was good. Grandma was okay.

Best pizza in the world. I moved out of NY but any trip back means a visit to Lenny and Johns.