Alright, Frankie. Out here in Jamesport, Long Island, and pizza was on my mind. A buddy of mine with a summer house out here suggested we hit this spot, for some pizza I would be pleasantly surprised with. He wasn’t wrong. Lenny’s has a great above average slice, something I didn’t think I could find outside of the 5 boros. The regular slice had great sauce, and came out perfectly, after requesting it well done. I would have liked a little more crust, which influenced my score for sure. Overall, If you’re out here in Long Island and pizza is on your mind, Lenny’s is the spot. They had a plethora of specialty slices too, and the eggplant was great!
sgt.pizza1/6/21, 7:04 p.m.
Regular: decent crispness to the dough, not enough sauce. Cheese is standard. Pretty greasy 6.3 Buffalo chicken: dough cant support the weight of toppings. Chicken is cooked well sauce tastes good but Its a greasy mess. 6.5
pmw9/7/20, 7:27 p.m.
Good crisp base, lot of oregano, sauce could have been a little sweeter. Good cheese, little greasy, great crust. Good quality slice.
pellonious10/13/19, 12:48 a.m.
Good pizza. Nice tang to the sauce good cheese. Crispy crust. A little too floppy but overall a good slice
brybryyyy7/25/19, 5:12 p.m.
Thin crust pizza w no crunch, floppy and just ok... disappointed bc it says brick oven... scoundrels.
richie.speruggia7/4/19, 1:59 a.m.
I was a little weary when I saw Lenny’s had a 6.6 average but it was love at first bite. The cheese taste good and has a nice mouth feel. The pie was a little light on the sauce but it does have a nice tang to it. The crust was nice and crispy, cooked to perfection.
joanna.wenchell3/29/19, 10:48 p.m.
So good, I forgot to take a picture before devouring it. Sauce amazing
bobs0733/9/19, 5:47 p.m.
Decent slice for the North Fork. Thin crust good sauce. Cheese appears to be less than top shelf.
tommy242412/7/18, 6:08 p.m.
Thin and little crust , dough isn’t great, sauce and cheese is decent but overall not impressive.