Lenny's Pizza & Bistro

Good sauce and thin crust

Regular: decent crispness to the dough, not enough sauce. Cheese is standard. Pretty greasy 6.3 Buffalo chicken: dough cant support the weight of toppings. Chicken is cooked well sauce tastes good but Its a greasy mess. 6.5

Good crisp base, lot of oregano, sauce could have been a little sweeter. Good cheese, little greasy, great crust. Good quality slice.

Good pizza. Nice tang to the sauce good cheese. Crispy crust. A little too floppy but overall a good slice

Alright, Frankie. Out here in Jamesport, Long Island, and pizza was on my mind. A buddy of mine with a summer house out here suggested we hit this spot, for some pizza I would be pleasantly surprised with. He wasn’t wrong. Lenny’s has a great above average slice, something I didn’t think I could find outside of the 5 boros. The regular slice had great sauce, and came out perfectly, after requesting it well done. I would have liked a little more crust, which influenced my score for sure. Overall, If you’re out here in Long Island and pizza is on your mind, Lenny’s is the spot. They had a plethora of specialty slices too, and the eggplant was great!

Buffalo chicken slice with sesame seed crust

Crust could be better/crispier but flavor on point nice flop

Thin crust pizza w no crunch, floppy and just ok... disappointed bc it says brick oven... scoundrels.

I was a little weary when I saw Lenny’s had a 6.6 average but it was love at first bite. The cheese taste good and has a nice mouth feel. The pie was a little light on the sauce but it does have a nice tang to it. The crust was nice and crispy, cooked to perfection.

So good, I forgot to take a picture before devouring it. Sauce amazing

Decent slice for the North Fork. Thin crust good sauce. Cheese appears to be less than top shelf.

Good cheese to crust ratio, crust holds up to the fold.

Football pizza decent slice