Leonardo's Pizza

Great pizza pretty fast service

Got the thick crust style. Good undercarriage nice little char. Good amount of cheese and sauce. Sause could use a little more seasoning. Overall good pie.

No Flop. Always perfect undercarriage. Go to spot north of Milwaukee. Best pie I’ve had west of NYC. One bite isn’t enough.

Good pizza. Definitely recommend.

Solid flavor. Classic New York. Lack of toppings which was disappointing. Always a crowd pleaser.

Solid pie. Ordered it well done and that helped the flop but with the size of the slice and style of pizza only so much can be done. Nothing that will knock your socks off but certainly satisfying.

I’ve had the pizza twice, first got plain cheese, no special requests. It was a solid 6.5. Second time I asked for it well done. Brought the score up to 6.9. Minimal flop. Good crust. No slop.

I haven’t had Pizza this good in the Mequon area in my entire life. I don’t know why my family never ordered from here as we’ve lived 30+ years in the area. They were making fresh pies every time I walked in the door. The dough is delicious and the sauce is incredible. I’ll need to try it a few more times to see if the score goes up or down. They have great chicken-parm sandwiches as well 🍕

Brings me back to old Sicily. Grandma why did you have to leave me. Mamma mia!

Super Flop. Great

Solid ratios for toppings/cheese/sauce. Flavorful. A little greesy and floppy, but tastes great.

Jalapeño pepperoni and sausage. Tasted great. Perfect NY flop

Little greasy. Felt like it was just missing something.

Four bites, I don’t know the rules. Lots of flop, solid slice.

BEST NY Pizza in Wisconsin!

Good slice. Nice bit of New York Flop. Good crust

Absolutely best NY style pizza in Ozaukee County