Leo's Pizzeria

First off, this pizza would receive a much higher rating but the quality is the one of the most inconsistent that I have encountered. If you get the pizza with the right sauce on a good day, there would be no question of giving this a rating of 9, but on an off day it is not enjoyable and would get a low rating.

Cheese is good. Sauce is tangy. Crust was interesting… but gluten was a little over developed.

Good slice of pizza. Second best in Williamsport. Barts is still first in my mind.

this place is located in Williamsport. Maps must of never been updated but the correct address is listed on here. Ok so first of all, I’ve been told this is the best pizza in the entire city of Williamsport now for a couple years but the pictures always had me skeptical. Every pie looks completely different but when I seen Seth’s review, I knew they had the ability to make a high quality pie. When I walked into this place I came in with a hard on for pizza so I hope it’s not skewed but I think this place has potential to be in the high 8’s maybe even a 9.1. I’ve eaten at Sally’s in Connecticut and Angelo’s in Philly. Did a pizza tour of Long Island, been to New Jersey, and this place may have the best dough. It was amazingly light crispy and had a subtle sweetness. The pie tasted so fresh. The sauce was top notch. The only points I’m docking, is for the abnormal cheese ratio. I like light cheese, it was perfect on the other side of the pie. Now the other but I’m taking points off for, is the oregano. They put a bunch of it on there and I don’t mind oregano, but I think that should be left to the person to sprinkle on afterwards. This pie though was absolutely great and no doubt is the best in the city, and holds its own against the best in the country as far as I’m concerned.

This place is actually in Williamsport now (I think it's the same place anyway), but it's so good, I had to rate it. Thin, crispy, fresh ingredients. Pretty great pizza, particularly for central PA.

I refuse to be the one that puts this below a 9. In actuality I'd score it an 8.1. The ingredients were so fresh and amazing, they use the small Peperonis everyone should! The crust was SPECTACULAR! So why only an 8.1? It was flop city, wish the front of the pieces held up and were crisper. IF you live within an hour come here you won't regret it! (We drove an hour round trip, while on vacation).

Pictures won't do it justice. This is NY brought to north central PA. Williamsport loves ya!

Minimal flop great sauce good crisp solid solid pie good people worth the trip

Amazing crisp and flavor. Only place to get true New York style pizza in the area.