Lilly's Pizza

Really good stuff. Almost no flop

Pizza always either burned or not cooked. Dough taste like sugar and the crust is a dough ball. No bueno.

Ordered the original crust style well done, doughy/heavy pie, football pizza. Solid wings

7.1-7.3 too much cheese

Probably the best pizza in a 3 hour radius. I try pizza places all over and this.. this is good pizza.

Greasy, no flop, the crust is doughy and hard instead of crunchy, but the rest of it is good

I wanted to like this pizza because it is Lilly’s. But it is just too doughy for my taste. The crust was soft with no crunch at all. Average at best.

Fresh ingredients. To me the crust is iconic, it has a very unique sweetness to the dough, I swear I could pick it out in a blind taste test. Good sauce, cheese leaves a little to be desired. It’s a rookie score from the wife, 8, I originally agreed but felt slightly inflated typing it in, 7.8 for me

Alright Frankie...we’ve been here twice. Last time we got the traditional hand tossed pizza. This time, we got the thin crust (because it’s the better pizza in my opinion). Now mind you, the last time we came here was a week ago, so let that sink in. Both pizzas get an 8. I like the crust, it has a nice sweetness to it that is balanced by the sauce and the perfectly portioned and applied cheese. This pizza is, by far, the best pizza I’ve had in Raleigh (so far). Also, the employees are awesome. Keep doing good things, Lilly’s.

Weekday pizza > weekend pizza here

Nothing to see here, or eat. Terrible. I have no clue who gives this place the awards they do. Move on.

Football pizza. Very little crunch. Slight grease but good taste to sauce and cheese. Just too doughy for my liking.

Waited 45 minutes and it came out a little burnt, but overall pretty good. Pizza 6/10 and atmosphere 8/10.

Bootiful

Pleasantly crunchy crust!