vincent.monastra9/10/20, 9:58 a.m.
Had the regular and the cold cheese slice. The regular, was good burned my mouth badly. Sauce was alright cheese was good. The regular gets a 7.1 Cold cheese slice though it’s very good. Hot with cold mix together on a pizza that gets a 7.5 Overall experience I give it a 7.3
t-rex.pizza7/2/20, 10:36 p.m.
Flop city, no crisp, undercooked and very disappointing at this LI Classic
duncan.lundy3/19/20, 7:56 p.m.
This is ok. The best thing about it is how crispy the crust is. Everything else is pretty average. But definitely the best thing to eat drunk at 2am.
jay.marine3/16/20, 7:55 p.m.
Ok so I’ve been here a hundred times... I got 1 reg/1 cold slice because they’re awesome. Scored the regular obviously... very good. Sauce, cheese very good. And gimmick or no gimmick, the cold slice is sick. Gotta try that if you go.
dustin.durham1/21/20, 1:07 a.m.
The sauce tasted funky to me. Very greasy and the crust was not crispy to my liking. Good drunk pizza.
chris.bozza11/16/19, 6:58 p.m.
i posted a long review before it got deleted this place is a longtime favorite that is better to order a whole pie at a time that being said i walked in there ... you can’t see any slices because their underneath the counter... i asked the guy i’ll take 2 slices of their warm you don’t have to heat them up he said they weren’t which was fine ... long story short 5.50 for 2 slices that were floppy and they were very very small ... a 16 inch pie cut in 8 ... this place has gone down hill even the pies that were coming out didn’t look that good... i was stuck eating crappy slices that i overpaid for oh well when i go back i’ll order the whole pie ... the overall experience wasn’t great how do you not display some slices on the counter ... the customer wants to see what he’s paying for very annoyed about that i think i’m being generous with my score ... dough was alright sauce good but just tasted like it was sitting there all day ...that’s about it ...
electric.nick10/25/19, 4:29 p.m.
Little Vincent was one of my favorite pizza joints growing up. Haven’t been there in a while, so I decided to drive by and grab a slice. I was very disappointed by the slice that was sold to me.
sushiguy10/14/19, 5:07 a.m.
Alright Frankie...This is the famous Long Island institution. Good pizza. Major flop to the point where it is messy. Great sauce and good. In Manhattan, this would be dollar slice quality but one of the better slices in Suffolk County.
sonnypizza7/26/19, 3:50 a.m.
Great sauce ! Lots of cheese. Cold slice rate 6.9. Regular slice 7.6. Wish you came Shawn, next time we need to go new haven Connecticut !
steven.hennessy7/11/19, 9:26 p.m.
Good crust, oily and New York flop! Sauce was good just too much oil! Cold cheese slice was much better 7.4
sean.marchia6/26/19, 2:16 a.m.
this was wack ... little vinnys more big grease , crust was OK though .
daniel.dorazio6/20/19, 3:52 a.m.
Little Vincents! This place has been around since 1972. At least that's what it says on the door, and I bet it hasn't changed a bit in 47 years. Why? Because you get this classic and strangely original feel as soon as you walk through the door. You got the old pictures of celebrities signing off to Vincent himself. Guys like Telly Savalas, Jackie Fontana and a bunch of other Italian Americans from the 70’ s. But overall you can tell this place is dedicated to one thing, and that's Pizza. Almost midnight on a Wednesday and there is a constant line flowing in ordering slices and and whole pizzas. And Vincent did not dissapoint in the pizza department. Awesome crust, crispy throughout. 4 slices in and still crispy. It has a nice savory sauce and a very distinctive cheese taste. This place came highly recommended. Definitely worth a trip to check it out. Check out my buddy Zac in the pizza pic with his Hawaiian shirt. He fit right in like that scene from "The Wanderers".
zachary.worthington6/17/19, 2:05 a.m.
Rookie Score, but thats what it deserves. Cold Cheese slice is ok and i suggest you try it but i liked the regular better. Slices were on the smaller side but the crust was great. Crispy and delicious. Savory herby sauce and a little heavy on the cheese but very good. The crust is what makes this slice.
matt.nars5/14/19, 4:14 p.m.
Don’t expect a large menu here, classic pizza joint, cash only. Super light and crispy. Very unique crust, overall very good.