Little Vincent's Pizzeria

Great flavor but a little wet & heavy in the middle.

More Long Island pizzas to review! First I tried the plain slice and then the one i’m really excited about, the cold slice! For what I saw the plain slice, it’s a little greasy, some flop, but the sauce and cheese is still good. It’s still a respectable slice. The cold slice is definitely a lot better, it’s less greasy and there’s not much flop. Cold slice: 8.3 Michael’s rating: 7.4

Boardwalk pizza flavor in non-large slice format. It is quite delicious all around with a solid crust. A bit greasy, but i’ll allow it as these taste like fresh ingredients. Ambiance also rocks, as I could very much see myself enjoying some pizza here after a night of drinking at 3AM.

A fixture in the LI pizza game. Great crust!

Cold Slice is the 💣 Cheese is outstanding!

Extremely overrated!!! As a LI’er I’ve heard of the legendary Little Vincent’s from everyone that lives in the area. Had a regular slice, cold cheese slice and pepperoni slice. If you put this Pizza in a lineup with slices from most LI pizza spots you’d choose many other slices over this.

Very sold slice great cruch best pizza i have had in Suffolk county

Super yummy & crunchy! Just wish the cheese would stick tg a little more but overall love it every time !

Beat pizza within at 20 mile radius especially at 2 a.m

I always remembered this being better than it was today. Had it years ago and was the best but something tasted different today. Good dough and crust, the sauce used to be sweeter and just didn’t have the flavor I remember.

So I came here excited cause the place is always busy but I’m guessing cause they used to be great and only places that are still open late . This pizza was bad. Crust tasted and felt stale and absolutely no flavor what so ever ! Bland is an understatement!! I had better from a gas station. Disappointed

7.2, overpriced and overhyped

Good slice. Not a great slice but a useful one. They put Panko or some kind of crumb on the bottom of the slice. Not a huge fan. Incredible sauce. Standard cheese. Lot of flop and a soupy feel which again, I like. If you’re going to prom, this slice isn’t your first pick, probably not your 2nd either, but when those doors close. You ask this one. Easier slice, but respectable. Not ashamed or have this slice meet your mom or take pictures by the pool with your friends. Also Little Vincent’s is normally open til 2am and ages well which makes for a great drunk slice. Sometimes an available 7.1 is better than a prude 8.5.

7.2 for the Regular Cheese and 7.1 for the Cold Cheese

Had the regular and the cold cheese slice. The regular, was good burned my mouth badly. Sauce was alright cheese was good. The regular gets a 7.1 Cold cheese slice though it’s very good. Hot with cold mix together on a pizza that gets a 7.5 Overall experience I give it a 7.3