Long Island Mike's Pizza

OK, first off for you novice pizza view “specialists” they don’t have Grandma slices here, they are Sicilian (there is a big difference). They didn’t have cheese so I got what they had which were very good! If I was going to make the Sicilian my score it would get a 7.9. Great undercarriage and crisp! The slice with pepperoni & sausage had the same great undercarriage & crisp! No flop, good amount of cheese and a nice tomato flavor. Would have liked a little more pull and chew but a very solid slice! 8.1

Crust was good and crunchy. Undercarriage was meh. Sauce was good and flavorful. Flavors were there but it was a floppy mess.

Ok, I might be biased. I am a Mike from LongGiland - West Islip. BUT… I will tell you this… the crisp is GREAT! And they don’t burn it! Perfect flop, still foldable but not greasy. I got a cheese slice and a pepperoni. Pep is EXCELLENT! This is my new favorite pizza spot in San Diego.

White, Buffalo, and Hawaiian are all in the 8’s. Pepperoni was floppy and greasy which I expect some with cooking pepperoni but it did drop the overall score.

My favorite spot in SD so far. Very good.

Great crust. A little floppy but overall a solid slice of pie.

Pretty solid, got the individual slices. Prob would have scored a bit higher if i ordered a large pie but this was still good. Their Warangal was very good especially with the knots.

I never go into the 9's, so this is right up there with some of the best I've ever had. Well done!

Love the sauce.

Solid pizza, especially for California. Good sauce and cheese. Crust was crunchy.

White slice nice Red sauce was good, Pretty crispy Good lunch deal. I like it

Solid pie, a little less crisp than I like but good. I am wearing a little sauce after my first bite on my shirt but hey that the price we pay right? This is a typical NY pizza, in the not so typical world of CA pizza so graded a little higher for that. Nice job Long Island Mike’s!

“Pac-man” Pie asked them to leave one slice cheese for my daughter. Pizza was very good. I liked the sauce a lot had a light aromatic smell. Cheese was classic and the cook on the pie was spot on. These folks know a thing or two about making Delicious pizza! Was very enjoyable on our trip to San Diego. That’s a solid score on a very nice dinner treat!💪🏽🧁🇺🇸

Really greasy which resulted in a lot of flop... would have been higher if not as greasy. Good crust and sauce

Good cheese pie!

Good!

Very good slices. The Cheese slice was solid. The Buffalo Chicken caught my eye in the case, and did not disappoint.

Good NY slice - flop and grease threw it off from being a 7+. Taste is all there

Really good pizza. Not a thin crust guy, but this was good. Perfect amount of crunch. Really good Buffalo flavor.