This is the definition of fancy, upscale Brooklyn pizza. A 3-hour wait to sit on a Sunday night, hour and a half wait if you wanna take out, and don’t forget: CA$H ONLY! You know what? It’s worth it! Light & airy, super thin, incredibly crispy & delightfully delicious. The dough is almost like a cracker but has phenomenal crunch & taste. The cheese has outstanding texture and bite. The sauce was a little lacking but still dazzles with flavor. The basil on top and Parmesan on the bottom round out a delectable pie exploding with tremendous zest. Believe the hype, set aside the time to wait and enjoy what appears to be a pie in the upper echelon of New York pizza. 🏆
max.trahan11/21/22, 9:23 p.m.
Had the composition of a great traditional slice with delicious sauce and approachable cheese. Not the centerpiece of the pizza like johns of bleeker but tasty and essential. Instinctually, the slice just felt like 8.8
barbermario11/18/22, 8:55 p.m.
Best pizza I’ve ever had I just wish I got there earlier to get a table so I can dine in! Every one was super cool when I ordered. I did a to go order and it was a 1 hour wait when I came back Lucali himself was there spoke to him before he left ! What’s a cool experience and got to see how the pizza was made !
10 views•0 likes
peter.mitchell10/30/22, 12:40 a.m.
Vibes were immaculate. Crust was perfect. Light and airy with a great undercarriage. Sauce and cheese were on point. Basil was excellent. The GOAT.
17 views•2 likes
christian.bowe10/29/22, 11:52 p.m.
WOW. If you are in the area no question. If you aren’t in the area buy a flight. Sauce was impeccable, crust was impeccable. Enough said. Get this pizza it is great. P.s it lives up to the hype.
floridapizzaman10/29/22, 12:54 p.m.
Came from Orlando, FL for this pizza. The undercarriage was the highlight of this pizza. Really good cheese and a light sauce. We tried the calzone which was great as well. While the pie was amazing, the service was really bad which ruined the experience for us. With that said, I will not let the service impact the score. 9.1 - solid! Be prepared to wait a few hours.
brendan.greenwood110/22/22, 3:43 a.m.
Without a doubt the best pizza I ever had. Get there early to get your spot. Will not at all disappoint pizza is insane.
krunchtime9/16/22, 4:35 a.m.
Easily one of the best pizzas you’ll find anywhere. Dough, sauce, cheeses… everything’s elevated to a higher level. The people there are extremely warm and welcoming also which stands out. Overall phenomenal experience. Thank you Mr. Iacono. Much respect.
mackenzie.nolan9/3/22, 5:13 p.m.
There is something magical about this pizza. Not sure you can really do much better than Lucali’s
sean.newsome18/7/22, 3:19 a.m.
A lot better than average pizza. I’ve had better, but this one is worth the travel. Still very overrated on this app.
thomas.moore137/30/22, 6:20 p.m.
The whole experience of lucali is incredible from start to finish easy 9.4 joint 2nd on my list for NYC
davidratespizza7/27/22, 9:31 p.m.
First flavor is the sauce, a thin tangy slightly sweet tomato sauce. Nice saltiness to the cheese. Good undercarriage crisp, the dough has a nice wood brick oven after taste. Would wait 45 min for a reservation again
pizzatour7/24/22, 11:55 p.m.
Good pizza but was not blown away by it. They use a unique cheese blend which makes it stand out.
titipizza7/19/22, 7:39 p.m.
Stupid light. Sauce that tap dances but doesn’t stomp. Worth the wait. Dump the hype out your head.
benji.timoner7/13/22, 6:14 a.m.
The. Best. There. Is. My favorite pizza and my favorite restaurant. Everything is lit here. Even the bathroom is class with a cool lil flush thingy if yk yk. Brooklyn baby. You gotta go period.
wrxsti876/23/22, 6:18 p.m.
Very basic pie that is not worth the wait in line to get a seat….if your dying to try it just get it to go and eat it on the sidewalk. Di Fara is far superior to this
kyle.varanyak6/20/22, 10:07 p.m.
It’s different from every other NYC slice, its light & airy….perfect crunch….its not better than Denino’s though
perry.keith6/12/22, 9:47 p.m.
Perfectly balanced slice of pizza. Insanely thin crust. Lots of crisp. Excellent ingredients. A true winner