Not often that pizza touches the 9’s for me but Lucali is no joke. Really frustrating experience to get a reservation (I tried and failed three times before I finally made it happen), but so so worth it. Quality of pizza at Lucali is second to none. The fluff / crunch balance is done to a tee, and the basil on top is the perfect touch. Don’t discount the amazing interior of the restaurant, either. Overall, the best slice I’ve ever had in my life, and it’s not very close.
john.harrop9/18/21, 3:02 a.m.
Fresh as hell, delicious more of coal fired fan myself but the care the pizza gets in that kitchen is insane, NOT a rookie score, had to be a nine but 9.1 felt a smidge high considering thats the highest i have given
pizzadoc.jv8/26/21, 3:14 a.m.
Excellent slice. Terrific flavor. Fresh everything. Sauce is perfectly sweet and has some tang and balances well with the cheese. Excellent char. For sure try this place if you can. 8.9 from me for sure!
adrianxsands8/22/21, 6:02 p.m.
A little bit overhyped but still very good. They offer a military discount, which is really cool. The pizza extremely well prepared and cooked, definitely one of the best in NY.
kgupta8228/15/21, 3:18 p.m.
Amazing pie, crust is crispy, pizza and sauce was on point, def amazing and all reviews are corresr
terry.redican8/10/21, 2:32 a.m.
Lucali …. Ridiculously good …. 9.58 to be exact …. Only thing better was the company ….. 10.0! #redicangirls
91 views•4 likes
stephen.pfund8/8/21, 2:56 p.m.
What an amazing experience waiting in line just to get a seating time and waiting around dying to try the pizza. Well it lived up to the hype. Very thin, crispy, airy, and everything is amazingly fresh.
k.romani6/25/21, 6:43 p.m.
Did a self guided pizza tour. Tried John’s Of Bleecker, Sally’s Apizza and Lucali. Lucali’s was hands down the best! The crust is amazing, the sauce is sweet but out of this world. Yes the way they function for seating is odd, but get there early and plan on taking the 5pm reservation. We got there on a Wednesday about 3:30 and were able to get a 5:00 seating. BYOB is a great idea too! Loved everything about it, if I lived nearby it would easily be a regular spot.
jaydavis6/14/21, 5:06 p.m.
The best pizza I have ever had in my life. It was unbelievable. Couldn’t recommend it more. Just the plain cheese and basil is amazing.
lennoll14/24/21, 8:01 p.m.
I’m with Dave on this one. Fantastic pie... beautiful and tastes better than it looks. Crust is tender yet crispy, with a slight sour-dough taste. Sauce is sweet and tangy, and available as a side if desired. Great for dunking any extra crust. And the cheese is fresh and perfect. Wowzer. I’m moving to Brooklyn.
joaquin.ayala4/9/21, 3:43 p.m.
Excellent pie, fresh ingredients worth the wait. Pepperoni & Hot pepper combo is to die for.