jmpizza2227/4/22, 7:50 a.m.
Overall good pizza. Crust has great sharp crunch and nice undercarriage. Pizza is light and tasty with the fresh basil leaves being a complimentary add on. The crust is a little too wide and could use more sauce/cheese coverage or pizza could include a dipping sauce to go with the pies. Service was also quick and efficient on a Sunday early dinner.
chuckpie6/30/22, 11:22 p.m.
Lucali Miami. Was very good . Heavy on the hard cheese , but good . Could have used a bit more sauce . But crust was top notch . I live way closer to the Brooklyn location but have yet to go. Over all good experience.
the_candyman4/26/22, 1:03 a.m.
The crust is to die for. Place was alive on a Monday night. Amazing #8.5
ryan.rutherford2/20/22, 7:47 p.m.
🌴BEST IN FLORIDA ALERT🌴 The sexy South Beach sister restaurant to the original Brooklyn Lucali location, Miami’s version matches the energy & ambiance of the BK joint and comes damn close to replicating their pizza. They must be getting the NYC water flown in or the dough is made in BK, cause this is incredibly close to the original Lucali style and taste. True to form, this is like a thin-crust bar pie style meets traditional circular football pizza with extra pizzazz. The dough is thinnish, firm, full of flavor, crispier near the outrageously crunchy cracker-like crust. The sauce is a symphony of sweetness & spices, as the puréed tomatoes sing with flavor bursts, accompanied by the fresh basil enhancing the strength of the sauce with each bite. The cheese is a blend unlike anything on the planet. A sharp, biting, delectable, tight combination of mozzarella, Parmesan, and some other surprises that creat pure magic. The grated parm or pecorino Romano underneath prevents moisture buildup and adds a slightly salty taste. The sauce to cheese ration is pizza perfection; you can really taste the freshness and quality of the ingredients. The char around the crust is as close as you can come to capturing the flavor and essence without burning the pie. If there’s any complaint at all, the crust is a tad too large; I’d prefer a thinner crust to allow for more cheese and sauce. Other than that, this is ridiculously close to the real thing served in Brooklyn, just a small tick below on the scoring scale. But this is easily the best pizza in Miami and most likely all of Florida.
b.karolchyk1/8/22, 10:42 p.m.
Great pizza. Quality ingredients and great preparation. Only think not amazing is the sauce. I’ve heard it’s not quite and good as the original. It’s really good, don’t get me wrong; but I feel like it could have been stronger. Overall good pizza. Drove 2 hours for it and wasn’t disappointed. Didn’t wanna give it the rookie score of a 9 so I went 9.1. Very great spot.
zzpizzadog10/31/21, 5:36 p.m.
10. Flaky cracker crust, sauce has just the right amount of amazing flavor and kick. Cheese is amazingly high quality. I don’t give 10’s but this is perfect wonderful delicious made in heaven to die for pizza. Aside from the pizza the Ambiance is a mix between old world Italy and New York. So much fun and a perfect pizza experience.
emcvlogs10/28/21, 3:01 a.m.
Really good pizza; the crust is my favorite super crunchy and thin! Only reason they didn’t get a 9 is due to price
10 views•0 likes
chris.kazianis10/3/21, 8:39 p.m.
I understand Daves comments on the parmesan cheese but this pizza is definitely higher than his 8.1 . This could get into the 9’s on a good day. Will be back!
court.marshall8/19/21, 10:08 p.m.
Best pizza I have had in Miami. Perfect sauce to cheese ratio and nice crisp crust. This is a can’t miss
kyle.marcinick7/22/21, 1:43 a.m.
Very different type of pizza from Mister O1’s. Took a fortnight to get our drinks out and anything else. You want experience ? Ship to Mister O1s. Thinking La Playa Market and Roman Empire finale next question.
joe.kneebusch7/4/21, 7:41 p.m.
This pizza tasted similar to Best Pizza in Brooklyn, New York. I only liked Best Pizza better because I was not a huge fan of this crust. Crust was slightly burnt and whenever you take a bite into the crust, crumbs fall all over. Other than the crust, overall I liked the taste of the pizza. The basil leaves on the side that you can add onto the pizza is a great addition.
subdiver6/25/21, 6:12 p.m.
Super high score, super pizza here! New king of Miami I think, might be a tad bit better than Mister O1. Near perfect crust, sauce and cheese!
steven.moncada6/15/21, 4:47 p.m.
Not Brooklyn but real tasty dough. They did a good job trying to recreate Carol Gardens vibe.