Lucille

Spot on for a good Wisconsin pie!

Pepperoni and mushroom. Much better than deep dish options

Honestly one of the better pies I’ve ever had. It was fresh and the under carriage was amazing. Every bite was fresh and I added hot honey. Highly recommend

Not hot enough. Tangy sauce. Good crisp.

Great balance for the crust cheese meat done perfectly for detroit style

20 mins for each round of drinks. Over an hour for an undercooked doughy mess.

This pizza is gross - I get that Madison is a bad pizza town, but this was inedible. The whole pizza is hard to chew and each bite worse than the last

Good pizza but not great. Reminds me of mall pizza but lighter

Light and crispy. All the focus here is on the dough and tomato sauce, and both are done very well.

love the sauce, bottom is charred nice and the crust is perfect. Only negative i have is too much grease. Overall great pizza and this is now in my rotation of pizza places lol

Great doughy crust. Good undercarriage with little flop. Sauce is great but I prefer more cheese. Overall pretty good pizza.

Amazing atmosphere! 3-story building, really cool atmosphere with live jazz band. One of their ovens was broken and I should have ordered a larger pie because the crust was way too thick. The tomato sauce and cheese had an unbelievably amazing flavor which is why I gave the score I did.

Get the Queen’s pizza!

The pizza was really really fresh and I love that. There’s a lot on the pizzas which is good and bad. It was solid not the best I’ve ever had

I know this rating is high for this AP, but this Detroit style pizza is flat out the best thing ever! I have been here a dozen times and each time have gotten the best service and a mouthwatering pizza you can’t believe.

Good pizza. Cooked just right, good topping. Only complaint is could use a little more sauce.

Ordered “The Queen”. Absolutely fantastic from start to finish.

Good crust. Not cut all the way through. A bit of grease. Kind of saucy. Good environment great for a date night.