Top Restaurants

Lucy's New York Style Pizza

Lucy's New York Style Pizza

2770 S 25th E, Idaho Falls, ID

Pizza Review

0 likes

lee.johnson1 on One Bite Pizza App

lee.johnson1

6/11/24 12:42 AM

Could use more cheese, the broadway location uses more. But otherwise a solid slice. The sauce is pretty phenomenal. Very good undercard holds the whole thing together and has a unique taste of its own. So far Lucy’s at both locations is the cream of the crop in IF.

Pizza Review

matt.olesik9/18/24, 12:52 a.m.

7.0

I’m from NY and this isn’t authentic NY pizza, but it’s close. Definitely the best pizza in the area

Pizza Review

brandon.miner2/10/22, 2:31 a.m.

7.6

If you get out fresh, no flop, nice crunch and just right on the sauce. Although the Buffalo chicken is my favorite

Pizza Review

edward.davis12/26/21, 6:41 p.m.

7.7

Good tang in the sauce, and nice overall flavor. Crust had a great chew but needed a minute more to get the best crunch. Overall very good

Pizza Review

matttie232/23/19, 3:02 a.m.

7.5

I’ve had Lucy’s a dozen times. This time around we got their meaty and another specialty but overall this pizza is a solid 7.5. Great sauce and cheese and crust. Gets a lil floppy and greasy but best pizza in Idaho Falls

Pizza Review

shaun.mcgrane1/9/19, 2:04 a.m.

7.2