Lucy's Pizza

I really enjoyed this pizza, although both slices could have been a bit crisper they were enjoyable with a sauce that has a hint of sweetness I love, the plain slice was greasy and had a big flop that prevented it from going to the 8s. The Sicilian slice is also a 7.8, I just wish the sauce and cheese was a little closer to the edge although I know it's a corner slice. Very good for the Ossining area.

Great customer service. Very friendly. Good slice. Crispy/ crunchy crust. No flop. Classic football pizza.

Not bad pizza. Nothing fancy. Something I don’t mind getting for lunch but wouldn’t be something I’d seek out for dinner. Good sauce and the right amount of cheese, and the crust was nice and crispy

Great slice. Great crisp, strong undercarriage, cheese and sauce were very solid. Little too much flop and grease keeps it out of the 8s. Bonus review for the Sicilian: 4.7

Lucy’s has always been one of my favorites in west Chester. Crust is crispy but light and airy at the same time, cheese is good(not too greasy), and the sauce has a great flavor!

Excellent vibe to the shop. It’s clean and bright with about 5 employees. The sound of someone in the back of the kitchen pounding out fresh cutlets is heart warming. Served in 3-4 minutes and piping hot. Zero flop and the crust was cooked to perfection. It’s a very thin slice with a decent cheese to sauce ratio. The sauce is made fresh on site and is very good. They use a better than average mozzarella that is slightly oily. The dough recipe is very good. The only knock on the entire slice is that the sauce has no tang. Other than that, this is the second best slice I’ve had.

Best pizza shop classic I’ve had so far in the immediate Ossining area. Very cheesy, in the good way, but what elevates this is an excellent, flavorful crust that somehow was loaded with crisp after a 20 min box-job.

Solid slice overall.

Pie looked good in the box, a lot of flop, minimal crunch, average at best

Used to be the best in Ossining and lived at this place when in high school but it seems like they’ve dropped a bit overall. The pepperoni sticks are a staple of this place. And maybe it’s because of all the hills in Ossining but that cheese slid way too much for my liking.

Crust is delicious, though was a bit burned. Solid consistent taste throughout the slice.

Thin, crispy, decent size for a decent price. Wish the sauce was more robust. Tastes a bit salty. Pretty standard slice.