8,624 views•580 likes
tegan7295/6/23, 7:18 p.m.
Had to get the pepperoni because they were sold out of regular. Tons of flavor. Super crisp under carriage and crust. Zesty pepperoni and the sauce and cheese had a nice balance. Slightly greasy because of the roni but that’s to be expected. Must try if in the area
repsreviews5/4/23, 4:19 p.m.
If you like thin and crispy with no signs of flop the traditional is great! Just missing a little bit of spunk in the flavor to get it into the mid 8s. Still very good
michael.weckenbrock4/16/23, 7:10 p.m.
OG Bar Pie. Fantastic. Thin crust burnt cheese edges unbelievable taste between cheese and sauce.
pizza.couple12/26/22, 8:09 p.m.
Crispy and light. Classic taste. Tomato forward and smooth sauce. A delicious pizza for the everyday.
pizzamattv11/12/22, 1:15 a.m.
This Brooklyn style square is special stuff. Miles better than the normal thin
ua100210/14/22, 2:23 a.m.
Best square / football pie in the area. Great sauce and always just the right amount of cheese. Been coming here for years.
michael.beifeld8/20/22, 4:18 p.m.
The sauce was good and overall it’s decent but very greasy and the crust was too chewy. I’d eat it again - it’s good.
sixeightharry8/9/22, 10:27 p.m.
Interesting and delicious square pie. Like a thin crust Sicilian but not grandma style. Crispy.
buyprint8/8/22, 6:13 p.m.
Rustica… fresh tomatoes made this grandma style pizza a winner. No indoor seating, just pick up, outdoor available. set back off a busy street. Also had the regular square which was talked about and lived up to the hype.
darthpaul717/8/22, 10:46 a.m.
My son lives 10 minutes from here..we are born & bred NYC guys...after seeing Dave...we had to see...we're not disappointed...great flavor..no flop...reminded me of a thinner standard Brooklyn slice...great service from crew...a must see...
jmontyandlindabird6/30/22, 12:14 a.m.
We ordered a thick Sicilian pie. It was thinner than we were expecting but still very good. The undercarriage and crust have a nice support with just the right amount of crunch and chew. The cheese grease is just enough. The sauce has a nice flavor without being too over powering and the seasoning on top is a well balanced touch. Overall great pizza, on point with Portnoy’s review
kevin.price5/16/22, 10:36 p.m.
I went into this review with hi hopes and the score reflects my own expectations being surpassed as I could not find a flaw in one aspect of this pie other than there wasn’t enough of it. The well done cook was spot on as the cheese and sauce blended into that perfect mix I love and kill for in a pie with the bites so sharp. The cheese sauce ratio across the entire pie is dead on and the thing that pushed this pie into the nines are the center slices. The middle even had the perfect undercarriage and crunch in every bite no flop what so ever. And the edge of the crust was charred leaving my hands dark and an amazing crunch. This vaults very hi up my list not just in the area but possibly a top ten for me. It’s just right up my alley in every way and the guys were awesome and so was the place!!! It couldn’t have been any better:)