Mack's Pizza

No picture - forgot to take one

Sam’s is better

Sauce had some flavor, Crust was Crunch, Cheese generic. Not worth to go again.

Good boardwalk pie. Got it RIGHT out of the oven so that helped the score for sure. If you get it fresh it will have some crisp. Unique sauce and cheese was fine. Good solid pie and definitely above average in my opinion. Would absolutely go back. Two slices for 6 bucks in a tourist spot was a great deal too in my opinion!

Liked the sauce and cheese, underside was firm bur dough was a little soft. Cheesy, saucy, not too oily.

Very good

Sauce was Suttle and tangy. While cheese was tasty but may have to much. Crust for sure was the best part and had very little flop. But it was extremely greasy and messy. But all in all this is a below average pizza.

Great nj shore pizza. Got our GTL in, time to hit the pizza and the beach! 🍕

Not bad! Would have liked it to be a little more well done.

Mid but edible nuff said

Impressed honestly, I was expecting it to be a let down but it was actually really solid. Not as good as mancos though

Nostalgia tricked me here. Used to consider this as the goat place as a kid and growing up but latest experience let me down. Super grease and not enough sauce to cheese ratio. A mild let down but still decent.

It was good! Good crisp!

While greasy still one of the better options you can get in wildwood. I enjoyed it immensely.

Just as good as the other Macks. Ask them to crisp it.

Good, not great. fresh pie. no crisp. decent sauce. sinpar cheese.

Let me start off by saying they didn’t toss my slice in the oven for a quick warm up and extra crispness, so it was very limp and soft which I like my pizzas to be hard erect and crispy. But I digress. The sauce was alright nothing that blew me away but solid none the less. Cheese was average but not bad. I give this a solid 7.2

For some reason, this Mack’s Pizza at 4200 Boardwalk has way more reviews and higher scores than the original Mack’s located at 3218 Boardwalk in Wildwood, NJ, which I reviewed previously. Nonetheless, it’s virtually the same slightly above average pizza. The only difference between the pies I ordered was this one had a bit more grease gushing with every bite. Other than that, same thin, floppy, soft, somewhat soggy dough. Same cheese blend that tastes like mozzarella mixed with cheddar. And same tangy, bitter, oregano-flavored sauce that lacks sweetness. Both locations are packed in the summer all hours of the day. Can’t call in an order, so be prepared to wait a minimum of 20 minutes on most days. Decent pizza for the Jersey Shore boardwalk, but not legendary. Nevertheless, Anthony Mackrone’s true legacy lives on in the amount of money his pizzerias rake in every summer from the “Bennys” and “Phillies” that remain loyal customers from Memorial Day to Labor Day in Wildwood, NJ.