Here’s my first re-review... I originally gave this pizza a 6.3 or so. After an outcry of people claiming this is the best pizza (see Bills Mafia) AND a slew of newbies giving out 8’s and even a couple of 9’s, maybe I missed something? Perhaps they read my review and fixed what was wrong. Here we go... I’m not giving this a lower score out of spite. I’m fair, honest and detailed and with that said, what the @*^# is wrong with people giving this such a high score? Let’s start with the cheese. It’s standard, pre cut and takes a backseat to the sauce. The pepperoni slices were the only ones available and to be honest, this pepperoni is bad. It’s dried out and has a weird taste. Not going to dock points, just a side note. The dough, well, it did a great job letting the grease soak through to the wax paper. This was a very greasy slice. The dough was fresh but soft to the bite (due to the copious amounts of grease). The crust had minimal crunch. The sauce... wow. It’s sweet and it kills this pizza. I’m getting a bitter aftertaste of tomato paste. The seasonings try to shine through but the amount of sugar added to this sauce prevents that from happening. It’s sweet and worse than the last time I remember. Macy’s Place is completely overrated and needs an overhaul on this pizza.
sweatpantsjoe2/5/23, 12:31 p.m.
The Kenmore location is not on the app so I’m posting my review here. Their sauce is out of this world. Lots of cheese and pepperoni in every bite. I don’t give 9s out lightly but this is the best pizza I’ve had in Buffalo.
rare.snacks1/10/22, 5:54 a.m.
We ordered the pie and one of the guys mentioned I review pizza. Confidently the guy said I don’t care I know my shit is good….he wasn’t wrong this is a great pie. They hit it with some Chili flakes, and I don’t normally do spicy but it was so well balanced it really made it pop. The pepperoni was big cups, cheese was perfect. The sauce wasn’t super overpowering. This all worked well together in unison for a great pie. They also make a ton of crazy special pies I’m sure are amazing as well. I would definitely come back for another pie if there wasn’t 600 pizza places in WNY to check out still! @raresnacks_toronto on Instagram if you have a suggestion!
14 views•2 likes
seamus.smith1012/23/21, 6:14 p.m.
Without question the most overrated slice in buffalo. Lazy sauce, crazy greasy and overloaded.
gopanthers11/26/21, 6:45 p.m.
It’s heavy, messy, the sauce and cheese is quality. Excellent Buffalo style pizza.
jmau12410/8/21, 1:26 a.m.
This pizza is tough to eat. It's hard to pick up and you loose half the cheese. It's a thicker pizza and has a sweet sauce.
derek.hamm10/3/21, 1:01 a.m.
Usually I’m more of a fan of thinner slices but this is a very good slice. The slice was a bit old I expect it to be even better with a higher score as a fresh slice. Lots of cheese just a good slice all together.
585rocpizzaguru8/3/21, 3:35 p.m.
Really messy pizza, almost impossible to eat with out a fork and knife which I do not have! Plenty of roping and nice spice but shit it’s too messy!
chickenfingerpizza4/20/21, 11:53 a.m.
Love the use of whole fingers. I actually think the small pizza is better than the large for some reason.
buffalothiccboi12/2/20, 11:36 p.m.
Macy’s places *NEW* blueberry kush pizza with topping of gorgonzola, bacon, wild blueberry preservers, wild onions, mike’s hot
octobereyes8/23/20, 12:35 a.m.
Very greasy however cheese was very good and done almost perfect. Pepperoni good. Crust alright. Sauce sweetness perfect.
robc97/22/20, 5:38 p.m.
I really enjoyed theses slices and looking forward to going back. Liked the flavor and crunch. Not to doughy, a bit messy maybe because it just came out though
sean.pawlak3/11/20, 1:31 a.m.
Very good pizza wings a great too just not a true medium run a bit hot
90 views•2 likes
bryanpizzareview2/21/20, 1:00 a.m.
Best “Buffalo” pizza I’ve had in a while. The rumors are true really good pizza all around.
zach.hunter22/2/20, 3:58 a.m.
Really good pizza. Crust could’ve been a bit more done, but other than that I was very pleased.