Got the pepperoni and the vodka slice. Usually not that big of a fan of pepperoni or sicilians, but this slice was great. It had the just a little bit of kick to it and I wasn’t too too overbearing with the garlic
Order now on Slice
Order Made In New York Pizza
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
daniel.sagarna5/19/22, 8:55 p.m.
Little flop, good cheese, not much tomato sauce, a bit much grease. Overall solid, not the best, not the worst
eric.eze5/8/22, 3:41 a.m.
One bite everyone knows the rules. Mild amount of grease on top and moderate flop. Fairly crispy pizza though and decent flavor. What made this pizza was the crispy back end. My favorite part of this slice.
rushfan-duhpizzareviewdude4/24/22, 5:17 p.m.
Better. Closer to world class ny city pizza. Nothing jumps out but perfect ratio of ingredients. Bonus grandma. Rock solid. 7.9
goblue_8453/6/22, 2:27 p.m.
I subtracted a half-point from this score, as these were late-night, drunk, Friday night slices; too many pizzerias have now been beneficiaries of drunk scores on my end, so this was the reason for the subtraction. It also raised a red flag that this pizzeria was open so late. My original score was an 8.1 and I should’ve stayed with that, it was that good. However, you have to stick with the score you announce. Nonetheless, these were good, quality slices, and this pizzeria is well worth the stop.
wrxsti879/23/21, 3:31 p.m.
Very good slice the sauce has a nice tang to it. Great crust overall a good NY slice of pizza
bigdickslices8/28/21, 6:36 p.m.
This plain slice is quite satisfying. A good flavor on the sauce, not overly sweet but complements the cheese well. Great undercarriage, and a nice crunch on the crust. So many slice options here, doesn’t seem like you could go wrong with any of them. Certainly is made in NY.
fartsicie6/9/21, 11:30 p.m.
Sauce is super. Very sweet and it's perfect. Cheese I would say is average, but when you get a bite of oregano it makes it above average. Like the crisp to flop ratio. Crust was a little to airy for my liking. Overall a solid slice tho. Would get again.
sha4205/23/21, 4:27 p.m.
Margherita thin crust, Dave rated the Upside down slice 8.3 because of the "PrinceSt sauce" but this sauce on the margherita's is more tangy and zestier. The thin crust is also made with garlic butter, didnt try the regular margherita. Margherita thin crust score 8 The upside down slice score 7.2
jason.stone43/4/21, 2:11 a.m.
Both pies were delicious. Sauce is very tasty. Cheese was perfectly melted and crust was super crispy. Could’ve been a tad hotter. As a neighbor, I will be a frequent visitor
tour_de_pizza2/19/21, 10:54 p.m.
awesome undercarriage and great texture with the cheese. Loved the tang of the sauce especially on the margarita slice
rayzor3111/10/21, 11:04 p.m.
I didn’t go for the controversial spicy pepperoni slice but I got the upside down because it was fresher. Liked the flavor a lot. The sauce was great. A bit sweet, garlicky and spicy.
mdz33901/2/21, 12:05 a.m.
I’ve been to Made in New York Pizza a few times - it’s my favorite pizza spot on the upper west side. I always go in with intentions to try a plain slice but their spicy pepperoni slice/pie is too difficult to resist. If you are going to Made in New York Pizza for the first time, do it right, and go with the spicy pepperoni.