Made in New York Pizza

Decent under carriage Good ratio Decent sauce Decent cheese Thin, crunchy, hearty A tad deyyy

I enjoyed it! The cheese slice was very good— even though there was nothing absolutely showstopping, I felt that the slice was just a good all-around one for sure. Margherita was similarly good—I liked the sauce on it. Again, nothing absolutely over the moon, but a really good baseline for sure

Eye test - deceiving. Looks boring. It isn’t. Execution - really solid Ratio - perfect Sauce - actually jumps out. Fresh. Not a mountain of spice. Very nice. Neither over or understated. Dough - nice, subtle taste. Perfect crunch Cheese - not spectacular but fresh and impossible to find fault with Overall - good NY slice. Neighborhood worthy - absolutely Travel worthy - absolutely not J. Strauss said, “It’s the subtlety of variations that I find amusing.” Too good for Mets fans, although you’re all in hiding anyway

Must try their squares

Decent slice. No flop good taste and sauce. Crust seemed stale the more I ate it. Would try again

Overall okay, sauce was lacking and pepperoni did not satisfy. Hell of a crunch though.

Solid football pizza. Ratios were great, cheese was good, sauce was savory, and the crust was nice and buttery. Undercarriage was weak, very floppy, and not enough crunch. I also got a bunch of their specialty slices to go. I wore l score all them then higher than the gold standard slice. Also got them at 9:45 at night so that probably have affected the score. Think it would be better if you ordered a whole pie. Overall, it's a pretty good pizzeria.

This slice was Made in New York, alright! An above standard slice with enough firm to avoid a flop. Appropriate balance of sauce and cheese.

Amazing pizza!! Really sad I didn’t make it back for more. Guy working there had a one bite shirt on too 🤩

The “Prince Street” Italian pepperoni Sicilian slice has a great crunch and spicy kick, and even the basic golden circle slice is the best on the UWS

Wow. Crunch was perfection. Thinny thin was perfect. All ingredients proportioned perfectly. Best NYC pizza i have had so far. Must be new place. Check it out!