Made In New York Pizza

The cheese and Marinara Slices were solid. The Vodka slice was flavorless.

On 11/30/24 I had cheese slice and a Spicy pepperoni slice

Sbarro vibes but squishy and weird. They lie about their score on the wall art. Go get on the 1 and go 3 stops uptown and get Sal & Carmines or Mamas Too.

ABSOL

Was in NYC and wanted to try one of Dave’s highly rated places this was 7.9 so I thought I would give it a shot Really good pizza reheated well thin,crispy good sauce & cheese was delicious happy I stopped in

Big New York flop. Sauce is good but there is lots of sauce. In all fairness was my second slice was better than the first after it had cooled.

Excellent sauce great crisp. Overall great flavor. Buffalo Chicken good too.

simply delicious

Decent pizza. However, they got a 7.9 score from Dave in the video and on the app. So how come they have an 8.3 on their wall inside the store?!

rlly good, thin crust, tomato sauce has a very good flavor, not easy to come by. can def taste the love

This is very solid above average pizza

Had eggplant square and pepperoni slice. Worth it.

Infamously Made in New York has a beef with Prince Street Pizza, I had forgotten about that, but their square pepperoni slices are damn near identical. It's a square pan crust, but thinner than it looks from the top, cheese on the bottom, sauce on top and a shit ton of pepperoni. Square pan pizza is not my style, but this is the best version of that. It's got some very good cup and char pepperoni, contrast of softer interior crunch and moderately chewy outer crunch with being a hard dry crunch. Saucy on top but not super gooey with cheese on the bottom. The only thing messy and overwhelming is the doppio pepperoni on top. There's barely a half inch of space anywhere on the pie without pepperoni, so it becomes a grease pool. But if you're getting this that's what you're paying for. Gotta give them props for giving me a whole pie at the end of the fest, which reheated well after just 10 minutes in the toaster oven. That should make me give them a 10. But I got to keep it real, and not count that in the score.

very crispy light pizza, ordered the vodka pizza and barbecue chicken. flavors were all there, wish the vodka pizza was a bit spicier though, barbecue pizza was definitely it.

Agreeing with portnoy here