29 views•1 like
Best pizza I’ve had around Dunedin in a long time. Got the Maddie Ave! It was Awesome! Get some.
isaac.griffith9/16/21, 6:43 p.m.
Cheese slice is good. I like the crust and the cheese. Sauce is ok. Noah had the pineapple and ham slice he liked it gave it a 8.2. I think some of the specialty pizzas look awesome though. Can’t wait to try them.
justin.adams69/12/21, 1:03 a.m.
Good undercarriage,very little flop. Sauce is good too. Classic pizza
floridascott6/12/21, 12:23 a.m.
Pizza review here in the artsy, touristy town of Dunedin. Right before heading over the bridge to Honeymoon Island. 1.The name Madison Ave pizza I am assuming comes from New York's Madison Ave but they don't make mention of that relationship. 2.They say everything is made from scratch. I could see the gallons of NY water lined up in the back area. 3.Very large slice and had a decent flavor overall, and nice under carrige. They had the sign on the wall for them winning best of. 4. I enjoyed it almost to entirety, until I got to one clump of tomato sauce right at the end, and that one spot had no flavor to it. 5. My rating 7.7
knoah.solomon12/11/20, 3:08 a.m.
No flop solid pie got the white sauce will go back for normal cheese next time probably rate higher
eric.toliver10/28/20, 11:27 p.m.
This was about 10 minutes after I picked up the pizza and drove home. The crust was crispy and there was no flop. The sauce was sweet, the cheese was really good and there was very little grease. I also got a pineapple/jalapeño pizza that was also crispy but the toppings did slide off. Score is based off the cheese pie only.
u_wanna_pizza_me4/15/20, 4:21 p.m.
Alright Frankie...Madison Ave pizza. They are located on Bayshore Blvd though, so I’m not sure how that works. Good football pizza, but not as crispy as I would have liked. Crust had some crunch, but the rest of the pie was doughy. I liked the sauce. Nice balance of sweet and savory. But needs to be cooked longer to this pizza fan.
jacob.bjurholm3/4/20, 11:03 p.m.
Great Pizza, slices are huge, great sauce and cheese. Pepperonis tasted like out of the package from grocery store. Staff was very nice. All together great experience.
sam.cro8/5/19, 1:23 a.m.
The owner on his best day makes a good cheese pie. On my request he can make a crispy 7.8 cheese pie. Not a bad score. His delivery guy should stop answering the phone though. Not good for business. And for those of you rating pineapple pizza an 8+, please don’t review pizza anymore and stop putting pineapple on pizza ok!
jacob.gomes7/20/19, 11:31 p.m.
Decent pizza. Pineapple and pepperoni tasted better than regular cheese.
macho_the_man6/5/19, 10:15 p.m.
Madison Ave Cuban pizza The Cuban roast pork is slow cooked and seasoned for 14 hours. It adds the traditional sandwhich items of Ham, salami and pickle and topped with a mayo/mustard sauce. This is a fantastic pie that brings the taste of a Cuban sandwhich to pizza in a special way. Would definitely recommend!
dieselpizza6/1/19, 5:57 p.m.
This is average pizza at best. It’s not bad it just doesn’t do anything for you. The crust is actually really good with zero flop, the cheese is ok and along with the sauce it’s all kind of bland. Perfect drunk pizza. 6.8 that’s a review.
ryan.q65/18/19, 6:24 p.m.
Solid pizza! Great crust with just a little flop and the sauce had a nice tang to it. Just could’ve used more cheese though
bender90degrees4/13/19, 10:01 p.m.
Sorry I ate there the other day, forgot to take a pic, will be back for sure best pizza I’ve had in Florida EVER!
guapote563/3/19, 6:17 p.m.
Overall pretty good. Good flop and crisp, dough is a bit chewy but no real complaints. Cheese is good but sauce is a bit bland. Potential for a great pizza, just needs a bit more of a kick. Still can’t go wrong with it.