I’ve never had pizza in New York, or Chicago, or Detroit. I’m a Miami guy, and this to me is the gold standard as far as mom and pop suburban pizza places go. Magic City Pizza puts together what feels like the freshest ingredients around compared to other local joints to deliver a quality pizza all around. Often kinda greasy—which cost it a point—and ultimately a little floppier than I’d like, their plain cheese is among the best and most humble in town, and that’s just the cheese. Their specialty pies are all phenomenal, especially the White Pizza and Chicken Alfredo. The Garlic Knots are also unmatched.
