Name: Magoo's California Pizza
Address: 4919 West 38th Street null, Indianapolis, Indiana, 46254, USA
Telephone: +13172934411
Price range: $$
Rating: 6.3

Home

Top Restaurants

Magoo's California Pizza

4919 West 38th Street, Indianapolis, Indiana

0 likes

wilfordbrimley

11/19/25 12:33 AM

I ordered a small supreme pizza from mcgoo's. I ordered well done, but it didn't come out very well done. I made the mistake of getting the "garlic sauce", which is a goopy mess of flavorless alfredo-looking white sauce. All the toppings tasted like they came straight out of a can. I only ate two slices before giving up. Very poor quality. Even for free i'd have a hard time eating a lot of this

Order Magoo's California Pizza

Hungry? Order right now on Slice

Order now on Slice

andrew.khosrofian9/19/24, 6:15 p.m.

7.2

Great service. Man working the counter helped with a recommendation since it was our first time. Pizza was made fresh and came out at a good temperature. The same guy checked on us later to see how we liked it. Very friendly. Tried cheese, as well as the specialty pizzas: beef combo, chicken tikka and chappli kabob. Red sauce on the cheese was too sweet and heavy, making the crust soggy. However, the creamy garlic sauce on the specialty pizzas was delicious. Crust on the specialty pizzas was crisp every bite. Chicken tikka was my favorite. Chappli kabob was good as well, although a little strong on the coriander, but still delicious. Overall, the chicken tikka and chappli kabobs were a very enjoyable combination of flavors. A solid California-style pizza and would recommend giving it a try.

1 like

matthew.steward4/14/19, 4:09 p.m.

8.1

Chapppli kebab pizza.

0 likes