Main Street Italian Eatery

New spot no longer with the same name, average slice at best.

Good quality slice. Nothing flashy, football pizza. The Sicilian was good but could have been warmed up longer. 7.4 regular slice. 7.2 Sicilian

I waited a year or two before I tried this pizza again, and last time was awful and this time not that much better, very salty and taste some flower, little flop, not that exciting, crust was plain, won’t be going back unfortunately

Super good

Nice crisp undercarriage but a little slop. Good basic slice. Would come back.

Nice crisp, good undercarriage. Sauce was solid and ratios good. Basic slice.

Great crust

Great pizza love the sauce

Floppy, decent taste.

Unfortunately this pie was loaded with cheese, never a good sign when you pull a slice and end up with nothing but crust. Sauce is nothing to write home about either but the crust is great, crispy and saves the pie. Individually I would say Crust 7.9 - Sauce 5.5 - Cheese 6.2

Sicilian with roni I just love there pizza one of the best on Long Island!

Thin, crispy, tasty slice. Very solid. Not pictured here, but the square Vodka slice is great! Didn’t think we could rate that here, but that’s their signature slice! 8.8!

Very good for a small margarita personal pie. Sweet sauce, good cheese cover and thin crust.

Pretty good pizza, but a generic sauce flavor bumps this down a hair. Would get again, though.

Good pizza. 7.2 Done.