Maker Pizza

Expected a soupy neopolitan, but got a bomb ‘za that was incredibly tight and flavorful. Great stuff.

Solid pizza by Matty, this place and pizza kicks ass! Loved the crunchy bottom and crust. Also had a hint of doughiness to it! Yummy’

Banger of a slice Tasty sauce and pepperoni, soft on the inside but crispy on the outside & they threw a splash of parmesan cheese on it that really hit the spot

One bite… everybody knows the rules

Like an artisan heavyweight drunk pizza. Heavy, greasy, and cheesy. If yer into that awesome. One of these could absorb the alcohol of like 12 beers. Good for that style albeit kinda pricey.

This may not be Dave's kind of pizza, but it is my kind. Cheesy, salty, wall to wall pep. Amazing crust, but surprisingly floppy given the char on top

Tasteless pizza, very floppy. Cheese slides off , very greasy. Extremely overpriced!

Floppy, greasy and overpriced za!

Another fave. Very heavy football pizza but great ingredients.

This is great pizza, the ingredients are top notch. The crust is light and the char is perfect. Cup char pepperoni, sauce is balanced, it’s a sloppy fold em style pizza that is sure to hit the spot. One of the best in the city for a reason.

Phenomenal pie. The sauce, the crust, the flop, it’s all spot on. Gonna need to tour the big smoke more to try to beat this one

Probably the closest you'll get to a bona fide "Toronto Style" Pizza. Think NYC thickness and constitution but substitute a crust for a Neapolitan cornicione and you'll be almost there mentally. It's good! The 3 cheese blend used is a similar trick used by Di Fara (Block low moisture mozzarella, fresh mozzarella and a hard cheese like pecorino/parmigiano reggiano) and has great flavour and oiling. I happen to prefer Neapolitan pizza over all other styles so the score is reflective of my admitted preference here. In concept this could be the perfect pizza but I often found myself craving either the tenderness of a traditional Neapolitan, or the folding tactile feel of an NYC slice, neither of which Maker delivers. It is in the middle, but perhaps not the sweet spot, between these two styles. Still, if you can learn to love it on its own terms, Maker Pizza provides a thoroughly enjoyable experience.

Canadian pizza! Despite the picture, it’s super sloppy as when I picked up each slice, cheese and sauce was falling everywhere. But it’s solid in terms of its flavor and crust.

Large Pepperoni & extra cheese Very nice fluffy and slightly charred crust, pepperoni is very good quality, cheese & sauce are solid. Very satisfied

Order well done

Pesto was 9.2 - very herbaceous, loved it. It made me feel alive again. The mushroom was a 9.3 - really woodsy, think romantic walk with your partner in the woods! And the third pizza was a 7.8 with sausage and jalapeño, it’s missing something, much like one’s life upon introspection. Overall a great score 8.7.

Heard about this place on taste Toronto Instagram. Definitely lived up to the hype! Loved the crispy crust and flavourful pepperoni.

Forgot to take a pic 😬 Got the margarita which is a 3 cheese blend Sauce had quite a bit of garlic tang. Good or bad depending if you like garlic. I wasn’t crazy about it. Crust was good. Medium thickness and nice and fresh. Cheese was GREASY. Could be due to the blend Overall pretty good. would get again if I’m in the area but won’t travel for it. 7.3 that’s the review.

Really good pizza. Nice kick to it. A little bit too greasy though.