Mama Lucia Pizza

Reminds me of when I was living New Jersey. I never order toppings because their plain cheese pizza is too good.

A $23 large cheese pizza here. I guess that’s the price you pay going up to the North Hills. I was not impressed with this pizza at all. I tried the Downtown location last year and didn’t really like the pizza either. The Wexford location has way better reviews and the pictures look better too. Unfortunately when I opened the box, I was not getting a pizza that looked as good as everyone else’s. It was one of the greasiest pizzas I’ve ever eaten. The cheese, sauce, and crust were all substandard in my opinion. There isn’t really anything too redeeming about this pizza at all. All I can say is, it isn’t the worst I’ve ever had. Hopefully I can find someone to eat the rest of these slices since I paid $23 for it.

The price of these two are higher than the review score!! 😨 good cheese and dough, sauce is eh and tastes kind of sour. Overall decent slices of pizza. NY style wins over Sicilian.

Best NY style in Pittsburgh

Greasy and floppy but a great thin NY style slice

Little to no flop, good cheese, and little sauce. One of the Better slice of NY style pizza in Pittsburgh.

Minimal flop, perfect sauce and cheese amounts.

Best NY style I’ve had in the Pittsburgh area. Solid pizza.

A little doughy but good

Best NY style I've found in the Pittsburgh area

Very cheesy. Not a whole lot of sauce but the crust and the cheese make up for it. Not a lot of flop. Classic football pizza.

Good pizza, thin ny style, a little flop, little grease, good cheese, good sauce, the crust has a crisp, but hard to fully bite through...

Awesome. Best ny style pizza in the north hills. The best pizza I have found in cranberry, north hills, butler etc.

Major football pizza major flop! Little greasy. Great cheese and sauce.