Mama Maria

6.3–not amazing good for Delaware

Great owner and staff. Best pizza in Dewey/Rehoboth without a doubt. If you’re down here on vacation, make sure you get a pie.

Very cheesy and good tasting slice that is not overly greasy. However this slice is missing sauce it’s barely on there if at all. The crust is a perfect crunchy on the outside, soft on the inside. Easily one of the best “beach pizzas” I’ve had. Easily in the 7s with more sauce

Great crunch, solid pie

Very greasy but good tang

Basic Football Pizza. Solid crust with decent flop. A little heavy on the cheese. The sauce was missing some seasoning and some tang. Overall not bad though.

10x better than grottos

M Score: 9.3 Crust: 2.8 Cheese: 3.0 Sauce: 2.5 Bonus: 1.0 Ranch? No “Great sauce, just wish there was more. Perfect cheese. Wish this was local for us”. J Score: 9.4 Crust: 2.9 Cheese: 3.0 Sauce: 2.5 Bonus: 1.0 Ranch? No “Deceivingly delicious”

good slice

Not bad not great would not travel good drunk pizza

Solid pizza. No flop closest you can get to NYC in Dewey. Little greasy tho.

Very good margarita pizza, the sauce is excellent. The other pizzas are about a 6.7 but the margarita pizza is definitely buy worthy

Little too white on the bottom for me but it held the flop test. Nice bite to it but a lot of grease. Drunk Bar pizza at its finest

Crispy. Good flavor. Pretty greasy

Very floppy, strange cut...

This isn’t that bad. Slightly surprised. There’s probably better, but there is definitely worse.