Mama Mia's

Real NY style upstate. Crispy and cheesy.

Absolute gem of a place, best crust ever

Consistently delicious pizza!!!!

Dave Should check this one out. Very impressive for college town pizza. 👌🏻

Geneseo’s must eat. Great crunch on the crust. Cheese is great. A little too much grease.

Good undercarriage, great flop, could have had a little more cheese but overall a solid slice

Solid pizza! Needs to be cooked a touch longer to have better crisp on the crust but overall good pizza.

Very thin and tangy and crunchy

Very good crust. Nice crunch. Cheese and sauce proportions and flavor.

Cheese was the highlight of this. A great blend. Sauce was really robust. Crust was burnt. Killed an otherwise great pizza.

Great crunch - huge slice - OK sauce and cheese.

Nice crust. Good flop. Could use more sauce. Nice slice.

Need to step up the sauce: 6.6

Little cheesy, 6.4

Lack of flavor in the sauce, good crisp in the crust

One bite everybody knows the rules... Not much flop.. definitely a unique taste and definitely football pizza. Good pizza, not bad, not great

Best pizza in Geneseo yet not an incredible feat when the only other place is Pizza Paul’s