Mama Mia's Pizzeria

Kinda floppy and doughy but pretty good cheese and sauce, not a terrible pizza though

I LOVE this pizza. The crust is chewy and fluffy, the sauce isn’t overly sweet or salty. Cheese to pizza ratio is perfect! The bottom was crispy and thin. This is one of my top favorites in the city!

Good crunch, sauce is very tasty. Holds together well.

I gotta go high on this one. They’ve been one of my favorite pizza places in Erie for years (even before all the shenanigans that lead to a Netflix series). I love their fresh dough, their cheese and their house sauce, it all adds up to a very flavorful pizza. Not a bland bite to be found and the cook on this is always pretty good. I miss their old location but this one is right by my house so I can’t be mad at how convenient it is. And I know this is a pizza review but I have to mention how good their strombolis are too.

Great Pizza, Great place! Netflix fails to mention how good this Pizza actually is!

This pizza’s definitely not “the bomb”. Pretty average pizza shop pizza. Nice crust, bad cheese spread, pretty greasy. I’ll also go out and say this might qualify as a good drunk pizza, but not to die for.