Top Restaurants

Mama Nancy's Pizza

Mama Nancy's Pizza

3495 E Broad St, Columbus, OH

Pizza Review

0 likes

joseph.kroehler on One Bite Pizza App

joseph.kroehler

3/6/24 5:10 PM

Oh wow! I never give out 9’s… but as a Chicago native, and an expert deep dish pizza critic… this is outstanding! Rarely do you see deep dish done right, let alone knocking down Chicago staples, outside of the downtown area and Chicago burbs. Their sauce here is next level. Acidic, robust with Italian seasoning down to perfection… and the cheese, my oh my the cheese!!!! Chefs kiss!!!!

Order Mama Nancy's Pizza

Hungry? Order right now on Slice

Order now on Slice

Pizza Review

tom.davis79/30/23, 12:10 a.m.

8.4

This place needs more reviews! We tried the Detroit & NY style. Detroit is it! Thick crust but light and airy. Great sauce. Great crunch. Columbus…get here and try it!

Pizza Review

wvbearcat6/18/23, 12:58 a.m.

8.4

Tried all 3 cities, New York, Chicago and Detroit style. All were good, NY was floppy crust and i had it after the other 2 so can't give a fair score. Chicago was good plenty of toppings an 8.1, Detroit was my favorite of the 3, corner pieces were money 2 middle slices were also good but a little sloppy. 8.4 for Detroit

Pizza Review

david.s.armstrong5/5/23, 5:11 p.m.

7.2

The Manhattan. This pizza has a great flavor. Very good sauce under a mountain of cheese with old world pepperoni. My only criticism would be the crust was to thin to support the toppings.

Pizza Review

scott.hickman12/12/22, 8:25 p.m.

9.5

Fresh mozzarella cheesy cheese, awesome flavor fresh tomato sauce !! Some of the best Chicago style deep dish pizza. Can’t go wrong here 🥰

Pizza Review

charlie.elliott iii9/21/22, 9:54 p.m.

8.8