As close to a Perfect cheese pizza as I have ever had. Cheese was perfectly cooked. The sauce and the cheese come together like best friends while chewing. Dough was a little undercooked. Minimal crust, which is ideal. Not too greasy. No burnt bottom. How did portnoy not stop here?
thatsmydude2/24/21, 11:14 p.m.
Would be in the nines if the sauce was better. Kind of had a chili flavor to it which made a 7.9. My friend ordered double cheese and I gave it a 8.1. But that isn’t true to the sport. 7.9 that’s a review.
paul.o48/15/20, 8:38 p.m.
Portnoy should have come here while he was in Cleveland. Got large pepperoni, sausage, and mushrooms. Hot and fresh with a little flop. Right amount of cheese and sauce. Sauce has good flavor. The crust could use a little more crisp but has a really good flavor. Good crunch on the edge. Probably the most flavorful pizza I have had yet. Mama Santa's is definitely a place worth checking out in Cleveland's Little Italy. Great Italian vibe and atmosphere. Definitely old school Italian ristorante.
w_swashbuckler7/31/20, 11:07 p.m.
The crust was not that good. The rest of the pizza was good.
sasa.restifo7/3/20, 12:50 a.m.
Mama Santa’s is the best in little Italy CLE. Thin crust and crispy dough. Sauce is my favorite. It’s homemade, spicy and tangy. Cheese to sauce ratio-amaze. Wouldn’t change a thing about this pizza
dusenberry345/12/20, 5:18 p.m.
Sauce has a pasta taste but tastes very well with the cheese. Italian atmosphere in there for sure. Overall good pizza, nothing special but something you would tell your friends about
david.boyd ii12/6/19, 2:20 a.m.
Not excellent, or anything I’d drive 20 + minutes for. But, it’s a decent slice.
ricky.benedict10/16/19, 4:15 p.m.
Dave would be against this but if you order it well done it’s an easy 8 every time!
bigmo29710/12/19, 11:11 p.m.
I cried just like that baby in the back ground. People had hype this pizza up for me I was hoping for a 8+. However, had to go with my gut! 6.3!
36 views•4 likes
ken.lewis10/7/19, 4:24 p.m.
Just crispy enough, but not too thin, we got the small perfect size for two at lunch.
jklange9/27/19, 8:36 p.m.
Double cheese, pepperoni-well done. My favorite style is coal fire (which this is not).But this is a great “game-day” pizza. The sauce to cheese ratio is good. The crust is buttery and golden without being soggy, so it maintains a nice crisp texture. The sauce is good, almost rich, but not too over powering. If you like a little heat, add the pepperoncinis. It will be a little greasy but it is not an artisan style pizza. Perfect for game day.
chas.wolfe7/24/19, 4:45 p.m.
Good pie. Solid sauce.Soft crust. Really good the day after in the microwave.