Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Restaurant

I miss my good long island pizza

Decent slice. Thin crust was good and firm and there was the right amount of cheese. It could have used a bit more sauce, but it was still good.

Solid slice. A little dry

Very good solid pizza

Very crispy, sauce is delicious, really good slice 8.3

Has some New York flop. Good flavor. Good neighborhood pizza place.

very respectable slice

Mama T’s a staple in my childhood and still good today. Cheesy, good sauce and crust with a slight crisp. Overall a good slice.

Regular 7.8... Sicilian 7.6.... averaged to a 7.7!! Great sauce and crisp... Had a stuffed meat slice that was outrageous.

Margarita slice

Tbh it’s more like a 7.2 but gotta stick with the first score, still recommend giving it a shot

Overall decent. Some flop. Some grease. Very cheesy. Football pizza.

Great regular slice

Fell apart on me. Regular football pizza. Not much else going on. Buffalo chicken was great. All the buffalo flavor without too much heat 8.2

Upside-down Sicilian style pizza. Great slices. Definitely something to try

Very solid slice. Not enough crust which reduced the total score.